Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Society & CultureReligion & Spirituality · 1 decade ago

Poll: are murders and suicides automatically push to into hell?

I don't believe in heaven and hell but this is a questionnaire with only right or wrong answers.

1.If a soldier is on a battle field and shoots the enemy, but saves his fellow troops...does he go to heaven or hell?

2.If an enemy troop kills innocents to get to our own troops...heaven or hell?

3.a man kills his wife for cheating...heaven or hell?

4. a man kills his wife for stealing money from him...heaven or hell?

5.a woman kills her husband and his mistress....heaven or hell?

6.a man kills his coworker because he believes he has done something to get him kicked off of the board of directors...heaven, or hell?

7. woman kills an attacker in self defense...heaven or hell?

8. a child shoots his dad for molesting him for years...heaven or hell?

9. A follower of Muslim decides to change his philosophy and follow another religion, then is murdered for that decision to leave Islam? heave or hell?

10. a mother kills all of her kids to be rid of them, so she can be with her new boyfriend who hates kids.....heaven or hell?

11.A doctor in a trauma ward doesn't help a patient because he is a known serial killer.....heaven or hell?

12.A young boy mutilates and tortures a small dog/cat to death\

....heaven or hell.

13.a mother kills a child molester....heaven or hell?

14. a woman is abused daily by her husband, finally she is trapped in a kitchen while it's happening and she grabs a knife and stabs the husband, killing him.....heaven or hell?

15.someone gives up on life and commits suicide because there was absolutely no one to listen....heaven or hell?

16. a boy has his fathers loaded .44mag and shoots his brother for not wanting to play and his brother said no....killing the brother...heaven or hell?

17. a man in the name of his god kills thousands, upon thousands, by suicide bombing an area where 1000s of innocents are...killing 90% and those trying to save them.....heaven or hell.?

I don't agree with heaven or hell...i believe you do these things you redo the lifetime again. If you pass you go to the next life.

What are your opinions? I'd love to hear them.

Update:

halfadozen you only got that because you followed the diagram I set up to follow.

11 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I think there is an afterlife, and it can be good or bad depending on what You do in this life. I also believe that killers of the innocent and rapists are the lowest form of life imaginable.

    1.If a soldier is on a battle field and shoots the enemy, but saves his fellow troops...does he go to heaven or hell?

    God won't send Me to hell for killing Iraqi soldiers that were doing their level best to end My life.

    2.If an enemy troop kills innocents to get to our own troops...heaven or hell?

    Hell, if it existed. I wouldn't shoot up civvies to get to the enemy.

    3.a man kills his wife for cheating...heaven or hell?

    Straight to hell if it existed

    4. a man kills his wife for stealing money from him...heaven or hell?

    Straight to hell if it existed

    5.a woman kills her husband and his mistress....heaven or hell?

    Straight to hell if it existed, unless it was self defense

    6.a man kills his coworker because he believes he has done something to get him kicked off of the board of directors...heaven, or hell?

    Straight to hell if it existed

    7. woman kills an attacker in self defense...heaven or hell?

    Heaven

    8. a child shoots his dad for molesting him for years...heaven or hell?

    Heaven, self defense

    9. A follower of Muslim decides to change his philosophy and follow another religion, then is murdered for that decision to leave Islam? heave or hell?

    Heaven, martyr

    10. a mother kills all of her kids to be rid of them, so she can be with her new boyfriend who hates kids.....heaven or hell?

    Burn in hell if it existed

    11.A doctor in a trauma ward doesn't help a patient because he is a known serial killer.....heaven or hell?

    Tough moral conundrum, I don't know

    12.A young boy mutilates and tortures a small dog/cat to death\

    ....heaven or hell.

    URGH, when he gets old enough He needs the holy **** beaten out of Him I'll say that

    13.a mother kills a child molester....heaven or hell?

    Straight to heeaven

    14. a woman is abused daily by her husband, finally she is trapped in a kitchen while it's happening and she grabs a knife and stabs the husband, killing him.....heaven or hell?

    Heaven

    15.someone gives up on life and commits suicide because there was absolutely no one to listen....heaven or hell?

    I honestly do not know

    16. a boy has his fathers loaded .44mag and shoots his brother for not wanting to play and his brother said no....killing the brother...heaven or hell?

    Hell if it existed

    17. a man in the name of his god kills thousands, upon thousands, by suicide bombing an area where 1000s of innocents are...killing 90% and those trying to save them.....heaven or hell.?

    Fry

    I'm a killer Myself. I used to be a sniper as You know. I have seen combat and killed Men. I believe in a harsh code of justice. Even today, 22 years later if the man that murdered My Fiancee and unborn Daughter ever gets out of prison he will die by My hand. I believe it's a truly horrible thing but I also believe sometimes it's justified.

  • 1 decade ago

    1. Heaven Even in the Bible it says it's OK to fight for your country.

    2. Hell see above

    3. Hell In the Bible you could get a divorce for adultery and stoned to death.

    4. Hell If they are married what is his is hers and what is hers is his.

    5. Hell see number 3

    6. Hell do I need to explain?

    7. Heaven You can protect your self

    8. Heaven If He is under the age of accountability

    9. Heaven If you are killed for your beliefs and are martyred

    10. Hell Do you really need a reason here

    11. Hell He has an oath to help the injured, he is not a jury for this mans crimes.

    12. Heaven (a animal doesn't have a soul.)

    13. Heaven I assumed He was attacking Her, she can protect herself

    14. Heaven see above

    15. Hell suicide is murder

    16. Heaven The way the question is he sounds like he's under the age of accountability

    17. Hell First he committed suicide, second he killed 1000s of innocent people

    Source(s): All could change and ask forgivness and be Baptised and go to Heaven except for #11 because he's dead.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    If there is an afterlife then would it not depend on your own mind set. An all knowing anything + free will = Oxymoron, so there is no such thing as an all knowing God. The two things are mutually exclusive.

    Because if there was it would be totally evil, it deliberately creates robot sinners, and then tortures the poor unfortunates in a fiery hell for all eternity. It could not make any less sense if it tried.

    Practicing Shaman... quantum physics rocks.

  • 1 decade ago

    If there is a higher being who judges are worthiness for the afterlife, I doubt that being is stupid enough to think about life in absolutes like good/evil or heaven/hell. Any god worth a damn wouldn't see your brief scenarios as providing enough information to decide the fates of souls.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Jade
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    The question isn't whether who will go to heaven or hell. The question would be rather that individual had a relationship with God or not. Good works do not get you into heaven. hence..."depart from me i never KNEW you" All sin can be forgiven, whether you murder or steal. ALL sin. It is the choice of the indvidual on whether they want to live a life with Christ and follow him. Its not about what they DO...but rather DIDNT do. That would be, DIDNT have a relationship with God, and therefore become lost.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Well these are tough situation but killing is not the way so they would go to hell, but like if any fo these situation happens then try to avoid it or it u have to arm the person harm them were they won't die, killing is nt the right way it like saying if a woman cheated on you and you got mad an killed her is that right no becasue you are just as wrong as that other person. Remember what goes around comes around

  • 1 decade ago

    This is an interesting one... It depends on ur religion, but if u'r christian, and the one that causes those deaths regrets and feels sorry for it, he/she would go to heaven.

  • Gary B
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Not always.

    JESUS forgave ALL sins, including suicide and murder . . .and rape, and stealing, and lying, and all the thousands of others. But you have to BELIEVE that He did so. you have to ACCEPT the Gift of Forgiveness that He offers you.

    ONLY those that do not accept Jesus as Lord and Savior go to hell. There is no "good" or "bad" required. ONLY beleif in Jesus.

  • FROG E
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Heaven and hell exist whether you believe in it or not.

    A person goes to heaven if he has received the gift of salvation from Jesus Christ.

    If we reject Jesus Christ's gift of salvation , we will go to hell.

    It's that simple.

  • Esther
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Frog E gave the correct answer. The truth is very simple, as he stated.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.