Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Socialist healthcare?
Why do people, especally republicans, oppose socialist healthcare and governement run hospitals? I'm trying to find the disadvantage to this and can not.
18 Answers
- 1 decade agoFavorite Answer
It is advantageous to the poor and working class to have socialized healthcare. The poor will save more on health care expenses than it will cost them for private insurance and deductibles, so there is no logical self interest motivated reason for a person making under 100k to oppose socialized healthcare.
The wealthy on the other hand, the ones who can afford the media machine and run fox news.....they are the ones who will have to pay for it. We would be taking a huge chunk of change from them to help the less fortunate. They dont like that.
What confuses me however are all the poor people who have been brainwashed into voting against their own self interest. They have been convinced that the government is going to tax their manual labor to pay for the healthcare of people even poorer than them....they dont realize that they are some of the people who will directly benefit from socialized healthcare. They dont realize that their medical expenses would go down or that they wouldnt have to pay private insurance (in a truly socialized system, which is not quite what we have in front of us now).
I dont understand how these people have been brainwashed into voting against their own self interest.....I guess they think they are going to win the lottery and dont want to give a larger piece of it up to help poor people?
- akelleystr22Lv 41 decade ago
You can answer your own question by going down to a any public New York City emergency rm. Take special care to note how wonderful the ill are treated by hospital personal and the lengh of a time the ill have to wait before being treated. . The best time to go is on a Friday or Saturday evening thats when the real fun begins.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Oh, it is easy to find the disadvantages. First of all, you will have to pay lots of money every month for Obama Care. Then the government will decide if you get care or if you don't get care. All you need to do is look at a VA hospital, Medicare or Medicaid to see how good government runs healthcare. All three are a mess! And bankrupt.
- Anonymous4 years ago
simply by fact given our government's historic previous of dealing with/administering something, a topic is that the huge-unfold of amenities would be pathetically undesirable and not properly particularly worth the fee to taxpayers. study up approximately American Medicare/Medicaid and the VA well being servcies...those are government administered well being courses that coach how poorly the government could be depended directly to have any say in offering high quality well being amenities. i'm a veteran (and nurse), and am grateful I actual have deepest coverage simply by fact i do no longer desire to ought to count on the VA for my medical needs. The device is overloaded and does not have sufficient components to furnish high quality amenities. the government is time-honored with this, yet does not do squat to repair it so some distance as i can tell. And individually, i do no longer think of it particularly is my duty to pay for yet another US citicen's well being care. i can agree that the charges of well being care right here interior the U. S. are outrageous, yet having taxpayers foot the bill for those expenses for each individual isn't the answer.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- 1 decade ago
Because they oppose everything socialist for the sake of opposing "socialism." A term completely blown out of proportion by Republicans in the first place. Plus most of them are so far in the insurance companies pockets they won't reform and hurt their campaign funds.
- 1 decade ago
if you look closely , it's not that hard to find some major disadvantages in this obama care
1.socialized health care Will Cost Middle-Class Families and Small Businesses Billions , Though House Democrats don’t know (or won’t say) how much their government takeover will cost, here’s what we do know: the plan will make health care more expensive and hit the middle class particularly hard with higher taxes, rationed care, and new health care costs. As millions of families and small businesses are struggling to make ends meet while making responsible choices, this plan forces those that make responsible decisions to foot the bill for those who don’t.
2.what we all know , government run health care Will Cost Tens of Millions Their Current Health Care Coverage , ( it could be up to 100 million )
3.this will cost us JOBS ...The House Democrats’ plan would impose employer mandates and cost jobs by requiring some employers – especially some small businesses – to pay a new eight percent tax to Washington. The plan would also slap employers that are unable to offer coverage the government deems adequate with another new financial burden. These two new taxes will make it more difficult than ever for small business owners to reinvest in their businesses and create and retain good paying jobs. Using the economic model of the President’s own economic advisors, an employer mandate would result in 4.7 million Americans losing their jobs.
4.here is the most disguesting part , under obama care ... we will government bureacrats issue death sentences for senior citizens ! ..believe me :
i'm talking about about a 70 year old grandmother being told that there's a treatment that may save her life and a government bureaucrat denying her that treatment on the grounds that she's too old to be worth spending the money that's needed to save her life.
so, ... Instead of keeping patients and doctors in charge of key medical decisions, the House Democrats’ plan will give Washington the power instead. And if you’re outraged with what Washington’s done with the bailouts, just wait until you see what Uncle Sam does with your health care.
5.this will ultematly lead to raising taxes , ..on evrybody ..not just the "rich"
did you think that obama and his buddies will manage to pay for medical care for 100% of all Americans would require a tax hike on more than 5% of the population.
obama said that " he won't rule out a health care reform bill that includes a tax hike on people making less than $250,000 a year"
he will raise taxes on middle class ( he already broke his campaign promise when he signed the tobacco tax )
at this time , Democrats are considering everything from taxing soda, to raising income taxes on upper income people earning more than $200,000, to a federal sales tax.
a democratic congressman admitted that the health care reform plan would be financed with tax hikes.
i hope i was helpful ...
- -RKO-Lv 71 decade ago
No one seems to be listening! If you are able to afford your own health insurance - or if you're covered by an employer's health care plan - you don't have to make any changes in your medical coverage.
For those who can't afford insurance, or aren't covered by an employer plan, they will be able to receive quality health care.
The problem with 'universal health care' is that it MUST eliminate the profit motive (thus, eliminate insurance companies who only have PROFIT in mind, not medical care).
I think it would be easy to simplify things: just extend MedicAid and MediCare benefits to everyone. If this country can afford trillions of dollars for an unconstitutional, immoral and illegal 'war' - and then give $8.5 TRILLION* in corporate welfare checks (called 'bail outs' or 'rescue plans). we can afford to provide health care for every legal American citizen who is unemployed, sick, poor, elderly, homeless or hungry. -RKO- 07/17/09
Source(s): *Bloomberg News [and official U.S. Government data] Fall, 2008 - FrancisLv 71 decade ago
FFS, I wish some of you cvould get it onto your thick skulls that a country that has government programs does not mean it's automatically socialist. In fact, the ones with market economies AND gov't programs are doing a hell of a lot better than YOU right now, and it's due in part to the gov't programs.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Anything provided by the government requires taxes to survive. Taxes.....your paycheck. Government programs, government healthcare and the government itself is ONLY allowed to exist because YOU GIVE THEM TAX MONEY!!!! NOTHING IS FREE!!!!!
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Republicans oppose everything that can benefit the average person, they only like to line their own pockets.