Catholics,how confidential are your confessions?

They are confidential- a priest who reveals a confession is usually excommunicated.

The priest merely encouraged the robber to do thew right thing and turn himself in. He did not turn the robber in himself.

The Seal of Confession is absolute. If a *valid* Confession is made, the priest's arms are tied. priests have been tortured to demonstrate what advance into cautioned to them under the Seal, yet to my expertise, it relatively is extremely no longer in many circumstances broken. The priest can order the penitent to confess his crime to the State, yet he can't do something outdoors of the Confessional. I in no way understood the subject human beings have with this. this supplies an option for a criminal to get some good and private counciling. Making priests make a record on sins to the State isn't in common words tyrannical, besides the easy certainty that it may furnish up criminals from going to priests for suggestion (which may be to teach themselves over).

How about a link to the story as your allegation is very serious and if a Priest did so without the Penitents permission he will be excommunicated....Then if what your telling is correct it sounds to me like the Priest told him he must make restitution and the criminal gave him the money to turn in for him so as to not be tempted....Ok i found the Story and the Priest did no more than call the Police and return the money.....

Perhaps the man didn't reveal under the Seal of Confession, hence, making it ok for the priest to hand him in.

I believe that most confessions are confidential. I personally doubt that I have told my priest anything that he hasn't already heard.

They are supposed to be completely secret, although, if you confess to robbing a bank, the priest would encourage you to turn yourself in.