Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Anonymous
Anonymous asked in Pregnancy & ParentingParenting · 1 decade ago

How can anyone with any intelligence say that a child doesn't need a mother AND a father n their day2day lives?

I understand that a gay couple will love a child and provide for that child. Early in a child's life, having two moms might not be that bad. But when that child becomes a teenager, who is he going to go to for dating advice? I know that I went to my dad for these type of things. What is a boy rasied by two moms going to do? Don't tell me that this child will probably have an uncle or another relative to get advice from. There is no way that uncle will be able to replace the role that a full time father has on a son. He is there to lead by example to his son in his everyday life.

I just don't understand how anyone can say with a straight face that a kid doesn't need a mom and dad. Moms and dads both have different elments that they bring to the table when it comes to parenting.

In general:

Moms PROTECT the child from the world.

Dads PREPARE the child for the world.

Its this system of checks and balances that lead children to be balanced adults.

There has to be someone out there that has some freakin common sense that understands this.

Update:

Okay, can you please refrain from using the worn out excuse of single moms and dads raising kids. Those kids are missing half of their biological parents, so I feel for them too. We need to fix that so there aren't so many divorces.

But how does purposely making kids have no dads fix anything? If you put a kid into a lesbian home, that kid is guaranteed to NEVER have a father. Two wrongs don't make a right.

Update 2:

Some of you have made my point for me. I'm not even saying that gay parenting is wrong, I'm just saying it isn't the ideal situation. Its people who are so into their political agenda that are blinded by what should be common sense. Having a mother and a father is the BEST way. Doesn't mean that is the only way. But for someone to say that in general, a kid doesn't need a dad or a mom, well that is just plain silly. Of course he does. Does he get it always? No, sadly he doesn't. But in general, how can anyone, gay or straight, deny that the best environnment for a child is with a loving MOM and DAD?

I do respect the gay and lesbian couples who have taken kids out of the system and given them homes. Is the method the best? No. But its better than that kid having nothing.

Now do I think a lesbian couple should be able to get pregnant, have a kid, then shut the biological father out of the childs life? Absolutely not. Gays can adopt, but shouldn't be allowed to birth.

Update 3:

By me generalizing the roles that a mom and dad perform, I see I have ruffled some feathers.

Parental styles do vary from parent to parent. This is not my opinion, this is fact. Look it up. A dad is a different influence on a kid than his mother. Why do you think when a kid hurts himself, he goes to mommy most of the time? But when a little boy climbs a tree or learns how to throw a football, he calls for his dad.

Its really simple people.

It takes male and female dna to produce a child. Doesn't it just make sense that it takes a male and female to raise one?

And don't give me that bs about single moms and bad hetero marriages. This isn't about them, so stop trying to change the topic.

29 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    oh I see, b/c some one thinks differently then you they are an idiot with no common sense or intelligence!? If dating advise is your main reason for stating this ridiculous rant then I am sorry, you seem to be the one lacking in proper parenting department. I also resent your blanket statement that father's prepare the child for the world. Are you kidding?? Most mother's not only protect, but prepare the child for life. They are the ones doing most of the child raising since Dad is off at work most of the time.

  • 1 decade ago

    Well I think you are an idiot. While I have no experience with gay parents, both my parents died when I was very young. I'm raised by my uncle. So is my sister. I have no motherly figure. and my uncle would never dream of trying to be my dad. I do just fine. I can protect myself and have taken down a few guys who were out of line. As for a mom. Why exactly do I HAVE to have one? I don't need somebody to tell me what to do, or give me advice. I'm smart enough to know right and wrong. I can cook, clean, shop, whatever. I miss my parents, but I don't need them to live. I'm a happy, independant person. There has to be someone out there that has some freakin common sense that understands this, as you say. I am a very well balanced person. You, on the other hand, may not be.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Well thats true. Perfect families are quite rare now. i know 5 people whos mums and dads are still together and only 2 lots of the parents get along. Or what about single mums or dads, widowers, a parent who is in prison or something like a drug dealer.

    Sure mums and dads bring the preparation and protection. But why cant you grow up perfectly norm with mumS or dadS. Surely your not going to end up a unbalanced if you purely have two dads or two mums. As long as your loved, thats all you need to grow up to be a good person.

  • 1 decade ago

    i can prepare my son for the world, though all parents need to protect there kids from the world when they are young, don't say as a mum i'm not gonna be able to teach him how to be an effective adult. i consider that my duty and have already started as has every other mum. yes it is most beneficial for a child to have male and female role models and authority figures but theres no reason why 2 men or 2 women can't do it. plus have you never heard of aunts or uncles?

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 1 decade ago

    well bc in all honesty a child doesnt NEED two parents. it is the ideal but isnt necessarily needed. i agree with you that children should have two (or more) loving and supportice fully active parentsin thier lives. but i am from a very blended family where i didnt always have both myu parents in my daily life, and i am ok. i came out of my expereinces feeling all the love and support in the world. as the sister of a lesbian who has a child with her parnter, that child has alot of love and just as much support as a child with opposite sex parents. they just make sure that the child has some active male influences also. it really depends on each individual situation and family. and also the child.

    I do not agree with you generalization though. there is no set thing, in general or not, that each parents provides to the child. i am preparing my son to do alot of things. and my husband is very protectiv eover him, sometimes more than myself. and those two things are nowhere near the complete job description of a parent.

    so i guess i am on the fence with this one. i agree with you- but to a point.

  • 1 decade ago

    What you are saying is understandable but that's just like saying that single mothers can't raise men, in which they do it everyday. Yes the ideal parentship is a mother and a father but just because they don't have both doesn't mean that they are a lost cause. Because even some children that do have a mother and a father don't turn out so hot.

  • 1 decade ago

    If my straight uncle and aunt can raise a gay kid, then it only stands to reason a gay couple can raise a straight one.

    I was raised by a mom and a dad. My dad broke my jaw. My mom signed me away to keep from having to leave him.

    I would have preferred 2 loving parents of the same gender.

    Or even 1 loving parent of any gender.

  • Me
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    I understand what you're saying and agree but I feel you are missing one component. These kids before getting adopted by a gay couple have no one, that's right no one who loves them and cares for them. Having two parents, even if they're not one male/one female standard parents, is better than nothing at all.

  • 1 decade ago

    Don't agree. Sorry. I think having a mother and a father in your life definitely helps and can make things easier, but I know many people who have turned out just fine with one or the other. I came from divorced parents and my dad wasn't a huge role in my life, but I had a lot of love and turned out just fine. Sorry to burst your bubble. =)

  • 1 decade ago

    Children need a male and female role model in their life, that doesn't necessarily mean a mother and a father. He/she can come in the way of grandparents, aunts, uncles, cousins, friends, etc.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.