Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Is continuity of consciousness an illusion?
Is the person we thought we were last week already dead, and we merely inherit his/her memories? Do we have a concrete identity/self?
There is no diety, so if you think there is, don't bother.
Priscilla, the evolving and building, not dying part makes a lot of sense to me as well. I don't understand why this requires a man-made diety, and that's probably not what you're saying. Here is my working answer. I know it all sounds a little Chinese poem-ish, but I hope this makes a bit of sense.
I'll use a rivulet example to explain how I think of this. Let's say your consciousness is a rivulet of some substance running down a tree. The front end of the rivulet, as it makes its way down the tree, is current experience. Everytime you go to sleep or get knocked out, the rivulet merely stops. It still has the rest of the rivulet (what brought it there) behind it, or further up the tree, it's just not currently flowing.
There are other substances (other people) flowing down the tree as well, and those can shape your path, as well can the bark (outside experiences).
This way of viewing things answers a number of questions.
Continuity of consciousness is not an illusion. Where we are now on the tree is a product of which way the rivulet went before, and we can still see it further up the tree...it's still "us" and it doesn't matter if out current state stopped for a while (sleep/temporary unconsciousness).
Also, this explains the fact that if you clone yourself (create a rivulet of the same substance), you don't achieve continuity of consciousness. The only way to achieve eternal consciousness is to upload the brain onto a non-organic substrate (substrate independence for the win!).
Caleb, I'm not talking about the brain in a vat argument, although there are some interesting and highly logical arguments for such a view. I encourage you to read this paper by a leading philosopher: http://www.simulation-argument.com/simulation.html
I'm talking about the idea of the Self and the continuity of experience, building up to become what we would call the Self. Is it continuous? Are we the same "person?"
8 Answers
- Anonymous1 decade agoFavorite Answer
Even concrete changes over time. When you look at yourself in the mirror, you are looking at yourself slightly in the past. By the time the light hits your eyes, you've already changed. Given that we only know what we experience, and that we have yet to know everything about ourselves, we cannot be fully conscious of our identities in any moment. If you accept that all things change, then we are as concrete in our selves as any other matter in the universe.
- 6 years ago
This Site Might Help You.
RE:
Is continuity of consciousness an illusion?
Is the person we thought we were last week already dead, and we merely inherit his/her memories? Do we have a concrete identity/self?
There is no diety, so if you think there is, don't bother.
Source(s): continuity consciousness illusion: https://shortly.im/hdlQQ - 1 decade ago
If your whole life is an illusion, and there is no possible way to escape it or prove it,,, accept it. A perfect illusion is , for those being veiled, reality.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
42
- Life GuruLv 71 decade ago
5000 years of philosophical gymnastics has concluded that we cannot hope to go beyond proving the existence of our own consciousness that is when we get to that stage if ever. You on the other hand was able to conclude, there is no deity :)
- Priรciℓℓα ✟Lv 71 decade ago
I have no idea. I used to worry about that. I talked to an older, wiser person about it and he told me that no, we aren't dying every second, we are building upon our old selves. Evolving, not dying. Made a lot of sense to me.
Source(s): I believe in a *Deity*, hope you'll forgive me for answering :-P - 1 decade ago
Republicans never change, because they are afraid to. so they are the same people they were a week ago;)