Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Trending News

Promoted
?
? asked in Society & CultureHolidaysRamadan · 1 decade ago

Shia sources, clearly fabricated?

This is something a shia pointed out to me, i didn't even have to do any research...

The book(Al-Kafi) is widely considered the most authentic of shia hadeeth collections. Its author (Kulaini ) was among the greatest and most respected shia scholars in history; for example:

Al-Najashi has said, "In our people al-Kulayni was the chief scholar in Ray, Iran. He was the most reliable in the matters of hadith.

Al-Tusi , the great scholar has called him the most dependable expert in hadith, the man of highest esteem and a scholar in hadith.

Al-Majlisi : "He is unparalleled among all the scholars we have seen. The study of his compiling hadith, his manner of editing them, proves him to be a Divinely gifted scholar.

IT CLEARLY SAYS ABOUT THEIR GREATEST MUHADDITH THAT HE EDITED AHADITH. RSPONSES COMMENTS ANYONE??? MAY ALLAH GUIDE YOU TO ISLAM

Update:

If this is the most authentic you have, doesn't all of your sect just fall apart. I apologize if my behaviour has not been the best reacting to the shia, but I am in such shock that you can follow this sect and continue to slander the best of the followers of Islam, The weight of the faith of Abu Bakr alone is more than the faith of the rest of this ummah.

Update 2:

Sahih means authentic, if it really comes from the one it is said to have come. If someone brings you a recording of someone's voice, that is an authentic narration from that person, its not about one being more authentic than the other, if it can be proved to come from the prophet than this means it is authentic. Don't make it seem what its not, if you guys don't bother so much about seeing if hadeeth are authentic, then why would you break apart from they way of the companions without evidence to do so. A muslim bases his faith on daleel and evidences, not falsehood that you can admit to.

Update 3:

To sincere-advisor, i'm sorry but all of muslim scholarship disagrees with you, bukhari and muslim dedicated their life to compiling only authentic ahadith, over time after they had past away, muhaditheeen went back to check their work and when they noticed how sound and meticulous they were, thats when their books became famous. Their collections are more authentic than the muwatta.

4 Answers

Relevance
  • Cute
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Hey,

    Salam =)

    I really hope people read your message with an open heart. The purpose of being here is learning/correcting ourselves so we may all enter paradise.

    I really hope people don't start fighting/taking it the wrong way.

    Just a thought.

    Anyways,

    Best Wishes =)

  • Sincere-Advisor
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    All Hadith compilers, except Imam Malik, were from Persia and included numerous weak or unsound Hadiths. That's why I only trust Imam Malik's Muwatta. Imam Malike lived all his life in Medina, and had first hand knowledge of Hadith narrators.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Al hamdoullah

    Allah Swt said they are content with the tenents they chose.

    So surely we have now only to see whom is not content.

    Source(s): Al Sunnah
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    The authenticy of Kitab Al Kafi is discussed here in this link

    http://www.shiachat.com/forum/index.php?/topic/234...

    Any objections is none of my care, if ur not satisfied with my answer, than go blow urself up, or blow Yazid for all i care,

    we dont worship our hadith books the way you do to Bukhari and Muslim, we dont call it 100% Sahih for a reason, since only Quran is 100% Sahih, u wanna believe in other perfect books, than thats CLEAR shirk and kuffir

    all i ask is u practice what u preach, if u claim to truly follow Sunnah, than follow it to every minute of ur life, not act like a dam barking Mauwiyah than 2 minutes later u turn into some Shiekh act all pious

    Sunnah you follow and the Sunnah of Muhammad SAW, has nothing to do with each other, hope i helped.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.