Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
What is your opinion on people who keep a dog from 6 to 8 weeks old and then dump her at the pound at 14 years?
I posted a question a few days back concerning GSD rescues and a 14 year old GSD that had been unceremoniously dumped in our animal shelter because of... (quote) "A gross looking growth that was grossing the family out." They left her there with the comment that they wanted the animal control officers to "gas her, shoot her, or whatever it is they do... too gross for us to handle and we do not want to watch her die." (Our animal shelter does NOT gas. We have a vet that handles euthanasia.) The family had owned this dog since she was a puppy ... 6 to 8 weeks old. Knowing the area, most likely six weeks.
She has a tumor that is about half the size of a bowling bowl, most likely mammary. I am posting the pictures I promised on that question.
http://s947.photobucket.com/albums/ad316/eaglesden...
She does have a rescue. She has been to see the vet and the tumor will be easily removed. We were told that it is most likely benign, especially considering the size, it is not attached, and the dog checked out to be healthy other than this one thing and a cyst on her left ear that should be lanced. She is obedient and loving, and moves fairly fast for a senior dog. The tumor is quite large and its location does tend to slow her down. She has a lot of strength though and I am very glad she is obedient. If she were not, she would be walking me. A senior breed specific rescue has stepped up and will take her. They notified us today that should the tumor check out to be benign, as we all suspect, she already has a forever home with a wonderful lady who needs someone just like this dog. Needless to say we are pleased we will not have to euthanize a dog that can be treated, even though she may only have a short time left. She will be spending the remainder of her days in a loving home.
Too many times I have seen people take an ailing dog to the county animal shelter rather than to the vet. Most times, if the dog can be helped, the rescues will make every attempt to help the animal and our officers are wonderful. They have the rescues numbers posted and will call right away. They have heart... a lot of heart. I am so sorry for those counties who must deal with animal control officers who do not. In this particular case, we were all in shock.... a 14-year old GSD that seems to have been well-trained and cared for ending up in this situation. It would appear all care stopped when something "looked gross" to them. They were told a rescue would help with vet costs if that was an issue. It was not the issue. What was? "That thing looks gross and who knows how much longer she will live with it." (Novel idea...have the "gross thing" removed.)
I would love to hear your thoughts on this.
Thank you in advance. I will not give a TD for honest responses and BA will be selected.
She is going to a wonderful home. Our vet is about 90% cpnvinced we have a benign growth... she is just too spry and NOT sick for it to be malignant, and all of you noticed the exact same thing we did...how darn long has the tumor been there? It did not get that large in a week, nor a month even. I also suspect this dog had some kids that spent some time with her, training her to sit and stay, etc... then went away to college and was left with parents who were most likely all too happy to see the kids go. She has some ear scarring which would indicate fly biting in the summer from being in the yard. But wonder of wonders...she is not heart worm positive so at least she had the preventative. I suspect one of those kids provided that. Guess the kid is gone now and will be surprised to learn the dog is as well when they come in for a visit.
@Memphis Belle: What a beautiful dog!!! I can only imagine the feelings my question must have elicited for you. I do wish all dogs could be with owners like you. I imagine I might sleep a little more at night. Thank you for sharing.
@ Miss Manners: You can believe he is already shopping for a new dog. He was looking at the puppies while he was at the shelter that day. So here is this dog in a kennel watching her "master" abandon her while he looks at new pups. None of our "mutts" met his needs. I really think we should have some kind of rule about these things. But it would be very hard to enforce.
26 Answers
- DeletedLv 51 decade agoFavorite Answer
I can't understand that kind of immaturity from ADULTS. Have it removed! Pretty simple. When an elderly parent becomes ill do you just dump them in a nursing home because it's too gross? Oh I forgot that happens often too doesn't it?
This annoys me so much, I clean up my incontinent Maltese's accidents daily, imo that's alot more gross than a tumor that can be removed. If I'm fifteen and can take responsibility for my animals why can't grown ADULTS? A dog is for LIFE, through the bad times, and the good times. Why can't people grasp the concept of that? Not everything is fluffy fur, and milk breath, puppies age, and some things aren't pretty.
People need to take responsibility for their pets and grow up.
ADD: My Maltese is 11, and also has cancer, we've had her since I was 4, and I can't imagine not having her, chances are we won't even have her for another 6 months. (estimation by the vet.)
People take so much forgranted.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
Disgusting fools with no life. They shouldn't be allowed to EVER own another dog. When you get a dog, it comes with the whole pack, which may or may not include those *gross tumours*.
These people simply can't feel love... Just look at the dog's face. Poor thing. I wish her the best luck!
I also have a similar story... Of these stupid fellas who abandoned the dog about 2 miles from their household, the dog CAME BACK, and they still had the heart to send the dog away... Or those people that will get rid of the dog because it doesn't match the carpet. EGH.
- ClumsicalLv 61 decade ago
those people sound like jerks. If they would have been responsible and taken her to the vet, that "gross thing" wouldn't even be there anymore. They probably just didn't want to deal with her anymore because she was old and they wanted a new puppy. I hate people like that. Dogs are so much cooler when they're older, and a lot smarter and more well mannered. But with what it sounds like, it's probably a good thing that they brought her in instead of "gassing" her themselves.
EDIT: just looked at the pictures... First of all, holy cow, that's a tumor. And second, that dog looks too happy and fun to be a 14 year old dog with a giant tumor and a family that dumped her.
- ?Lv 71 decade ago
The kind of person who buys a puppy, keeps it for 14 years, then dumps it because it has a gross tumor is probably the kind of family that kept her as an outdoor, neglected dog anyway. My parents had a cocker spaniel when I was in high school that had a massive mammary tumor. It was malignant, it oozed gnarly smelling liquid, and was downright disgusting and nauseating to be around. However, despite my horrid dislike for that dog in general, I would have NEVER dumped her at the shelter to be euthanized. When my parents finally got the nerve to bite the bullet and let her go they took her to the vet to be humanely euthanized.
The kind of person who just dumps their 14 year old family pet because it had an icky growth is the kind of person who went out and impulse bought a new puppy on the way back home.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- felixthecatLv 41 decade ago
Maybe when Mom & Dad start to get up there in years the kids will drop them off at a hospital with the message: "gas her, shoot her, or whatever it is they do... too gross for us to handle and we do not want to watch her die."
I question the quality of life the dog has had for the last 14 years as it does not sound like a beloved family pet. If the dog's health is failing then they should have the difficult discussion with their vet and consider putting the dog to sleep. But if it's just something "gross" you can't honestly tell me that this is the first gross thing the dog has done in 14 years.
- Anonymous5 years ago
In most states it IS illegal to part puppies from mother before 8 weeks. It is also immoral and unethical to even let any but the absolute top quality animals breed for any reason. Unless you have committed to do ALL of the following BEFORE breeding, you should NOT breed: 1. Contact a breed club for your breed. Ask for a mentor. 2. STUDY the breed standard. Learn about dog anatomy and ask your mentor to clarify anything you don't understand. 3. Learn what genetic faults and diseases run in your breed and test for any that can be tested for. 4. Show your dog in conformation events to see if it is of the proper quality for breeding. Winning doesn't always mean a dog is breeding quality, but being around so many others that know your breed and will talk to you will do wonders for your self-education efforts! 5. Study the past history of great dogs in your breed. You will see how your breed has improved and progressed since the beginning of the breed. 6. Study the breed standard some more! ;-) 7. Join any Yahoo groups about your breed. 8. Live, dream and study your breed. 9. Get a good book on canine reproduction, and educate yourself about the pitfalls, problems, and proud moments of breeding. Learn about the physiology of reproduction, such as heat cycles and venereal diseases in dogs, potential for problems specific to your breed, and what you need to expect at whelping. 10. Remember that whelping (giving birth) can kill your female. Being used as a stud dog can encourage bad behaviors common in intact males such as territorial marking, aggression, and desire to roam from home. 11. Prepare to be broke. Breeding properly is EXPENSIVE. 12. Line up potential homes for any puppies you produce and write up a contract. Remember to include that you will be willing to take back your puppies at any time in their lives that they might need you. If you bring life into this world, it is your responsibility FOREVER. 13. Prepare to spend sleepless nights attending whelping females, caring for fading puppies or puppies orphaned, and practice cleaning up after 24/7 poop machines. I'm sure there are many things I missed because being a responsible breeder isn't just a job. It's a way of life. You will live dogs. 24/7/365. There are lots of hard decisions. There is a lot of expense. There will be pain. But, if you do your darndest to always keep the welfare of your dogs and the future of any of their offspring, you can go to step 14. 14. Enjoy the love and success of a job well done.
- 1 decade ago
My thoughts on this are fairly strong......so I'll proceed with caution.
As you will see from the picture, my previous male Dobermann had major surgery to remove a huge aggressive tumor located at the base of his neck, which left him with an impressive battle scar.
Boris had just turned four years old when he was diagnosed with aggressive skin cancer & all I was concerned with was deciding what treatment, if any, was in his best interest. When I collected from the veterinary referral hospital post surgery & first session of carboplatin, he was sutured & stapled together, with a wound that would need dressing, but did I care? NO!!
I cannot even begin to comprehend the minds of the GSD's owner. I would have loved to have been in their position & had my dog 14+ years, but after living life to the full for a further 3.5 years, Boris developed multiple new tumors {unrelated to his original cancer} near his major organs & DCM.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/fallonbrooke/30487720...
I know that it's not easy placing a senior dog in a home, as people are reluctant to open their hearts to a dog when its life expectancy is limited, but so glad that someone has offered her the home she deserves.
- 1 decade ago
That breaks my heart. My family dog had to be put to sleep after a two year battle with cancer, he was covered with gross things, but he kept holding on because he didn't want to leave his people. That last Christmas he was hardly eating at all, I'd flown back and all the family was there again, he tried so hard to hang on. The vet had told us that as long as he wasn't showing any pain he could have the holidays with the family, he sent him home to die. He lasted just into the new year, once everyone had gone back to college and he was alone with my parents he stopped eating, the cancer was throughout his body, and they had to put him to sleep because he was in such pain. Even over a year latter it still makes me cry, and to think that someone could just abandon their dog, when the dog considered them their family.
- 1 decade ago
That's horribly sad, the poor dog. Evidently it was easy to dump the dog rather than taking time out of their busy schedules to get her to a vet and find out exactly what was wrong with her. If they have children, I'm willing to bet that's exactly what will happen to them (the parents) when they get old, disabled, just "don't look so good and who knows how much longer they'll live with all those wrinkles". How selfish. I'm glad that lovely dog ended up with your organization rather than being dumped on the side of a highway somewhere abandoned. And good on her, she's got a forever home, however long forever may be for her.
- AliceLv 71 decade ago
I think that the children who have grown up with this dog, assuming there are children (now teenagers or young adults) in the family, will very likely place mum and dad in the old folks' home as soon as they start to dribble and become forgetful.
I am not going to tell you all the trouble and expense we have gone to over the years, taking care of our injured, ill or senior pets, until the vets advised us that it was kinder to let them pass than to keep caring for them. I am sure many others have the same sort of stories, so I won't bore you with mine. But when it was time to euthanize an animal, it was always done at our expense and with us personally in attendance and I can't imagine doing it any other way, painful as it was.