Is Aaron Rodgers in the top 5 best QB`s to you?

Current active QBs, yes.

Top 5 ever, not even close.

Thumbs up to those who agree.

My top 5 is

1) Peyton Manning

2) Tom Brady

3) Drew Brees

4) Philip Rivers

5) Brett Favre

Aaron Rodgers would be the 6th.

1) Peyton Manning

2) Drew Brees

3/4) Aaron Rodgers

3/4) Tony Romo

5) Donovan Mcnabb.

Yep, he is.

Brady is way over rated, I only put him in my top 5 in 2007, and that was it.

Favre is too old, and he will retire.

I'm a cowboys fan and normally I would put Romo over Rodgers, but Rodgers did pretty damn good this year.

1. Tom Brady

2. Peyton Manning

3. Drew Brees

4. Aaron Rodgers

5. Philip Rivers

6. Matt Schaub

Though I think 4 through 6 can be interchanged at this point, Rodgers to me will be the best of the three. He's got physical tools the others don't.

1) Manning

2) Brees

3) Schaub

4) Favre

5) Brady

Peyton, well he's just Peyton, which is why he is the best.

Brees is pretty damn good, hell of a lot of TD passes.

Schaub threw for the most yards this season.

Favre only 7 INT's...7!

Brady didn't have a good year, but he's still up there.

So no, I would not consider him in the Top 5, but definitely in the Top 10.

NOTE - ONLY FROM THIS SEASON!

My top 5 are

1. Peyton Manning

2. Drew Brees

3. Brett Favre

4. Ben Roethlisberger

5. Phillip Rivers

But Aaron Rodgers is definitely up there :)

Not quite yet. With Warner and Favre gone, he does move into the Top 8. Brees, Manning, Brady, Roethlisberger, Schaub, Rivers and Romo are all better or equal in terms of pure ability.

Yes.

1. Peyton

2. Brees

3. Brady

4. Rivers

5. Rodgers

You certainly wouldn't think so from the relative amount of hype these two players get, but last season Rodgers played at a higher level than Favre has ever reached in his career. I'd take today's healthy Rodgers over a healthy Favre in his prime any day of the week.

yup....

1. Manning

2. Brees

3. Brady

4. Schaub

5. Rodgers

not quite. close though. after brett favre and peyton manning retires he will. but then again Jay Cutler could get hot(peyton manning has a 27 INT season so dont assume Cutlers 26 INT season means he sucks), Shaub is on the Rise, Big Ben is gonna be in there, Matt Ryan looks like the next peyton manning and give Flacco some receivers and he could be awesome

AND TO ALL THE PEOPLE GIVING THUMBS DOWN THIS IS AN OPINION QUESTION EITHER THUMBS UP OR NO THUMBS!

wow ALL of the thumbs down i got were after i made the last statement, i guess this place is FULL of haters

1. Brady

2. Manning

3. Brees

4. Roethlisberger

5. Rivers

Rodgers would probably be in the next tier though with the likes of Romo, Palmer, Favre, and McNabb.