A few Questions for Shias?

Question

Asalamu alaikum wa raghmatulahi wabarakatu

I am Muslim who follows the teachings of the four main Sunni mathabs to please Allah(swt).

I have a few questions for those who are SHIA's, or those who were Shia's.

These questions are not to insult or degrade in any way. I only want to learn.

There are a few things I've heard about Shia's and your beliefs and so on; some may be true, some may be misconceptions and some may be lies to divide the Ummah, I do not know, that is why I am asking. I would rather know about them from the Shia's about your beliefs than from others.

And again, I really do not ask these questions to insult in any way, these are only things I've heard and read. And if you do feel insulted in any way by my questions I apologize.
 
QUESTIONS:

1. 
Do you believe Ali(ra) was a Nabi after Nabi Muhammad(saw)? and why?
Do you believe Ali(ra) was suppose to be the Nabi instead of Nabi Muhammad(saw) and Jibril went to the wrong person? and why?
Or Do you just believe that Ali(ra) was one of the greatest Sahabah of The Nabi Muhammad(saw) and The Nabi Muhammad(saw)'s cousin and the rightful First Caliph?

2.
Do you believe that the Quraan is incomplete and that there is/are Surah(s) missing?
and why?

3.
Do you practice Mutah or believe that it is acceptable in Islam?

4.
When making Namaz(Salaat), do you Sajdat on a stone or something like that?

5.
Do you beat yourself? Why and when?


Again, I apologize if I insulted anyone.

Anonymous · Accepted Answer

1) No, No, and No, ur mixing Alawi/Nasrawi beliefs with the Jaffary Madhab...thats like me mixing Ahmedi or Sufi beliefs with Sunni beliefs

2) No, if we did, we wouldnt be reciting it in our prayers or keep it in our homes or use it to debate

3) No, Yes, keep in mind, its not always about sex, read up on Misyar, and how thats abused in Saudi Arabia and Egypt 

4) Yes, its called a Turbah

5) Its not beating urself, its mourning, andyes i do it, on the month of Muharram

fenimore · Answer

a million. A muslim woman is authorized to talk to strangers while dressed modestly, no longer in inner maximum and could ward off talks on trivial and devious issues, an identical applies to instructors. 2. Shias are a devious cult, aka Munaafiqeen, aka Sahaba Abusers, aka ''It hurts me lots ((: why did Prophet observed had to marry the daughters of Abu bakr and Omar RA??''

Anonymous · Answer

1-they believe 12 super prophets after our prophet PBUH 
as they says " Imams Superior to Prophets"

Al-Islam.org, the popular Shia website, declares that “the office of Imamate is a higher and more exalted office than prophethood.”  (Lesson Number 17, http://al-islam.org/leadership/) 

Grand Ayatollah Mohammad Fazel Lankarani, one of the Head Ayatollahs in the Shia Seminary in Qum, issued the following statements on his official website:

    Imam Ali (Alayhi Salam) is higher in rank than other prophets, because of his Imamate, but he is not higher in rank than the Prophet Muhammad (saws), because Muhammad (saws) was both Prophet and Imam. 

____________________
2-yes
the surat in qs is called SURAT AL-WILAYAT.

You can see the entire soorah, along with a telegraphic picture of the Persian mus-haf at the following site: 

http://arabic.islamicweb.com/shia/nurain.htm 

-->One of those who clearly stated that it exists is Mirza Hussein Muhammad Taqiy al-Noori al-Tubrusi (d. 1320 AH). He wrote a book in which he claimed that the Qur’aan had been distorted and that the Sahaabah has concealed some parts of it, including Soorat al-Wilaayah. The Raafidis honoured him after his death by burying him in al-Najaf. This book by al-Tubrusi was published in Iran in 1298 AH,

______________-
3-sure they are sons of mutah

_____________
4-why they did not stand up on a stone??why make Sajdat on a stone only??

__________________

5.yes

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSGvbkdhK4Y&feature=player_embedded

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YsZ7faPI6Hc&feature=player_embedded


MUD,NO MORE BLOOD......"Ashoora in Iran"
http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_qPqwJWUREoY/RhM2KpvrMSI/AAAAAAAAAMo/gx5VoMJFarI/s1600-h/2171253_bijariran.jpg

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_qPqwJWUREoY/RhM15pvrMRI/AAAAAAAAAMg/qh4QrpAkf2g/s1600-h/5e5120ac65.jpg

http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_qPqwJWUREoY/RhM2RpvrMTI/AAAAAAAAAMw/94P47NhGnqc/s1600-h/78cdc8c45e.jpg

These people will never cease to amaze me, no wonder I'm so drawn to keep an eye on what they do and say!!!

$ · Answer

MOLA ALI IS NOT AND NEVER EVER PROCLAIMED HIMSELF AS PROPHET ...NEVER!

MOLA ALI IS THE RIGHTFUL WASI, HOLDER OF KURAN AND HADITH. AND TO SAY YES CALIPH. AND THAT ALSO AFTER OUR HOLY PROPHET MOHAMED.

DURING THE TIME OF TRANSITION SOME TRIED TO CHANGE KURAN BUT FAILED

SAJDA IS IMPORTANT. TO ALLAH.

YES WE BEAT OUR SELVES AND IF I WAS ALIVE BEING A LADY I WAS READY TO FIGHT YOUR YAZID.

NOT AT ALL U HAVE NOT INSULTED ME

Unique m · Answer

plz ad me my yahoo ID is unique_rose67@yahoo.com so thn i wil answer u online i m shia one.

Anonymous · Answer

Bukhari:V1B11N626 “The Prophet said, “burn all those who had not left their houses for the prayer, burning them alive inside their homes.’”

Quran · Answer

WELL SAID

Trending News

A few Questions for Shias?

7 Answers