Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Do Muslims pretend that Jerusalem is important to them, only for political reasons?

Jerusalem is never mentioned once in the Qu'ran. Not once. Not even alluded to.

Muslims try to argue that this passage refers to Jerusalem:

Glory to He who took His servant by night from the Sacred Mosque to the furthest mosque. (Subhana allathina asra bi-'abdihi laylatan min al-masjidi al-harami ila al-masjidi al-aqsa.)

When this Qur'anic passage was first revealed, in about 621, a place called the Sacred Mosque already existed in Mecca. In contrast, the "furthest mosque" was a turn of phrase, not a place. Some early Muslims understood it as metaphorical or as a place in heaven. And if the "furthest mosque" did exist on earth, Palestine would seem an unlikely location, for many reasons. Some of them:

Elsewhere in the Qur'an (30:1), Palestine is called "the closest land" (adna al-ard).

Palestine had not yet been conquered by the Muslims and contained not a single mosque.

The "furthest mosque" was apparently identified with places inside Arabia: either Medina or a town called Ji'rana, about ten miles from Mecca, which the Prophet visited in 630.

The earliest Muslim accounts of Jerusalem, such as the description of Caliph 'Umar's reported visit to the city just after the Muslims conquest in 638, nowhere identify the Temple Mount with the "furthest mosque" of the Qur'an.

The Qur'anic inscriptions that make up a 240-meter mosaic frieze inside the Dome of the Rock do not include Qur'an 17:1 and the story of the Night Journey, suggesting that as late as 692 the idea of Jerusalem as the lift-off for the Night Journey had not yet been established. (Indeed, the first extant inscriptions of Qur'an 17:1 in Jerusalem date from the eleventh century.)

Muhammad ibn al-Hanafiya (638-700), a close relative of the Prophet Muhammad, is quoted denigrating the notion that the prophet ever set foot on the Rock in Jerusalem; "these damned Syrians," by which he means the Umayyads, "pretend that God put His foot on the Rock in Jerusalem, though [only] one person ever put his foot on the rock, namely Abraham."

Then, in 715, to build up the prestige of their dominions, the Umayyads did a most clever thing: they built a second mosque in Jerusalem, again on the Temple Mount, and called this one the Furthest Mosque (al-masjid al-aqsa, Al-Aqsa Mosque). With this, the Umayyads retroactively gave the city a role in Muhammad's life. This association of Jerusalem with al-masjid al-aqsa fit into a wider Muslim tendency to identify place names found in the Qur'an: "wherever the Koran mentions a name of an event, stories were invented to give the impression that somehow, somewhere, someone, knew what they were about."

Islam contains a recessive but persistent strain of anti-Jerusalem sentiment, premised on the idea that emphasizing Jerusalem is non-Islamic and can undermine the special sanctity of Mecca.

In the early period of Islam, the Princeton historian Bernard Lewis notes, "there was strong resistance among many theologians and jurists" to the notion of Jerusalem as a holy city. They viewed this as a "Judaizing error—as one more among many attempts by Jewish converts to infiltrate Jewish ideas into Islam." Anti-Jerusalem stalwarts circulated stories to show that the idea of Jerusalem's holiness is a Jewish practice. In the most important of them, a converted Jew, named Ka'b al-Ahbar, suggested to Caliph 'Umar that Al-Aqsa Mosque be built by the Dome of the Rock. The caliph responded by accusing him of reversion to his Jewish roots:

'Umar asked him: "Where do you think we should put the place of prayer?"

"By the [Temple Mount] rock," answered Ka'b.

By God, Ka'b," said 'Umar, "you are following after Judaism. I saw you take off your sandals [following Jewish practice]."

"I wanted to feel the touch of it with my bare feet," said Ka'b.

"I saw you," said 'Umar. "But no … Go along! We were not commanded concerning the Rock, but we were commanded concerning the Ka'ba [in Mecca]."

why do Moslems nowadays insist that the city is more important to them than to Jews? The answer has to do with politics. Moslems take religious interest in Jerusalem when it serves practical interests. When those concerns lapse, so does the standing of Jerusalem. This pattern has recurred at least five times over 14 centuries.

The Prophet. When Mohammed sought to convert the Jews in the 620s C.E., he adopted several Jewish-style practices - a Yom Kippur-like fast, a synagogue-like place of worship, kosher-style food restrictions - and also tachanun-like prayers while facing Jerusalem. But when most Jews rejected Mohammed's overtures, the Koran changed the prayer direction to Mecca and Jerusalem lost importance for Moslems.

The Umayyad Dynasty. Jerusalem regained stature a few decades later when rulers of the Umayyad dynasty sought ways to enhance the importance of their territories. One way was by building two monumental religious structures in Jerusalem, the Dome of the Rock in 691 and Al-Aqsa Mosque in 715.

T

Update:

M S: Al-Aqsa was built by the Umayyads and named 'Al-Aqsa' as a reference to the passage in the Qu'ran. In fact, the region of Palestine was called 'the nearest land' in Islam, not 'the furthest land', which is what Al-Aqsa means.

Also, it could not have built before the Jews left Egypt, being that Islam was not founded yet, and that Al-Aqsa is built on the ruins of the Jewish temple. That's what the Kotel is. You can't make up your own 'facts'.

Spanish Muslim: Please, spare us the propaganda bull****. Answer the question asked, or don't say anything. Just because you say it a million times doesn't make it true.

Update 2:

Also, M S, I don't think you know what Zionism is. I know you're using the word instead of "Jews", so maybe you'll look like less of a Jew hater.

8 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    it has been extremely common for muslims to desecrate the holy sites of other religions. ask any hindu, since a lot of the most important sites to hindus have been desecrated with mosques. it's a suppression tactic. by claiming the site, they think they can claim the preeminence of islam.

    so to prevent jews from rebuilding their temple, muslims put a mosque there and then claimed it was the site of mo's ascension, even tho this isn't supported by history or scripture.

    the birthplace of rama, an important hindu avatar is a mosque. the main church of the eastern roman empire was a mosque until they learned they could earn more money off of it as a tourist attraction. as they take over europe, key christian sites will become mosques as well, and new stories will be invented to justify their presence and lend credence to violent protests to protect them.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    i see u studied the Quruan very well because you couldn't find reason or proofs that Palestine belongs to jews. you trying to miss-lead the facts.

    its well know that Al masjed EL Aksa is the name not a reference. otherwise give me name of those early muslims!

    and Adna el Ard means the lowest part, near the dead sea. which is the lowest part. and that were the Romanies won.

    and when Muhammad asked where we should head our prayers , the answer were one answer to the al masjed al aksa. then God changed it. but the story u told isn't proved in the Sirah.

    And we have Hadeeth from Muhammad (peace be upon him ) that we should go to visit any mosque except 3: the one in Maca, and the other Madeena, and the third al masjed al Akasa.

    of course i ha vent told you yet about the story you told about Muhammad visiting the mosque and the proofs about that. which give us another holly reason.

    and politically i think arabs were leaving there before the english men came to invade it and give it the Jews? so it's their right to fight for it.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    The ultimate irony is that Islam swept through a HUGE area that would have encompassed much of the Jewish diaspora.... meaning that many Muslims and Christians in the middle east today are probably partially descended from the ancient Israelites. So who has more right to be there? An Israelite family that stayed in the Holy Land by converting to Christianity and then Islam over the generations, or an Israelite family that emigrated to Europe and remained Jewish over the generations? The idea that one ethnicity bears an ancestral "right" to be there is absurd.

  • M S
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    Jerusalem = al-Quds shall return fully Muslim soon

    al-Aqsaa Masjid was built by prophet and messenger of Allah Ibrahim as 40 years after al-Haram Masjid was built

    loooong before the 12 tribes returned from Egypt

    the LAST war on earth will end up with the end of zionism on earth

    all 3 Abrahimic religions shall RETURN 1 religion under al-Maseeh Isaa ibn Mariam as

    all very soon

    the killings of Palestinians/ Iraqis / Pakistanis / Afganisies all waste of life for tribal mentality by punsh of criminals who are breaking the Commandments

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ?
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Once the man invented god, to invent the sacred places was very easy

  • Achmed
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    It is not political it is religious. The white horse in Mohammad's dream is as the white horse that Jesus will return on in the Book of revelation. And in the dream he ascended into heaven as did the Messiah. And as the Christian New Testament says the Antichrist will kill many Jews so will the Muslim' messiah. They have taken texts from the Old Testament (Torah) and the New Testament to make their religion.

  • Sam I
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Liar!the holly land is mentioned in the Quran, in Chapter 17- Al-Eceraa.

    "Glorified be He Who carried His servant by night from the Inviolable Place of Worship to the Far Distant place of worship the neighbourhood whereof We have blessed" 17- Al-Ecraa.(1)

    The "place that God blessed" is the holly land of Palestine.

    Remember who KILLED God's prophet "John" ? they're Jews.

    Remember who KILLED God's prophet "Zakareya"? they're Jews.

    Remember who "tried" to KILLGod's prophet "JESUS"? they're Jews.

    They are called "Prophets Killers" !

    The same people who are KILLING Arabs/Palestinians.

    The land of "Prophets" will NEVER belong to "Prophets Killers".

    LONG LIVE PALESTINE !

  • Carl
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    When you make up a religion you can claim what you want, when you want, where you want.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.