Who is better Gerald Wallace or Josh Smith?

Josh Smith.

he can dunk,shoot and defend better than Gerald Wallace.

He's more clutch and overall athletic. i don't see how anyone can disagree with that.

I would take Josh Smith if i had to pick one. Both are extremely athletic and VERSATILE players, but I think Josh Smith being 6' 9" gives you more size and bulk. Plus Smith is one of the, if not THE best shot blocker in the NBA. Wallace may score more, but he is playing on a team with no scorers, while Smith plays on an extremely talented team, that is very balanced. Defense wins championship!

Man Josh Smith is better than wallace anytime. He has a bigger frame , is more athletic , more strong. Some answers told you to look at the stats and they thougt that wallace is better. WRONG!. Wallace is playing almost 42 minutes and averaging 18pgr,10rpg,2apg,1,5spg,1bpg , Smoov is averagin 15.7 pgr,8.7 pgr, 4.2apg,1.5 spg and 2bpg in only 35 minutes. It is a difference of 7 minutes man that mans a fifth of j smoovs playng time. So stats aint in gerald advantage , neither his game or his team. I think that josh smith playis with 2 big scorers joe johnson and jamal crawford

So Josh Smith owns gerald wallace

Josh Smith he is a good shot blocker a better defender than Wallace and a better re bounder and in scoring he averages 15 ppg thats good but wallace is a really explosive player dont under estimate him

Josh Smiths stats are a touch tainted because at the same time as Joe Johnson develop into healthful the Hawks coach didnt matter on Josh Smith. at the same time as Joe Johnson were given injured on the top of the season Josh Smith grew to develop into the first decision and he stepped up huge. He had an huge to triple double with 18 rebounds yet neglected it by 1 aspect with a win over Milwaukee. On March 19 he were given 26 pts, 17 forums, 5 assists, 4 steals, and three blocks. He scored 32 factors hitting 12 for 15 on March 10th. They gained all those video games. He averaged 3 blocks a pastime very last season. i imagine he will proceed to step up. identity bypass with Josh Smith, because the better effective participant yet both Gerald Wallace and Josh Smith are underrated because their communities at the prompt are not that good Josh Smith not in any respect fought inclusive of his teammates, he yelled at his coach once because he develop into hitting his pictures and the coach refused to enable him take the in simple terms suitable shot of the game. He develop into already mad because he had in simple terms forced a nasty shot and he wished to make up for it. Afterwards he apoloigized to the coach and his teammates.

Both are great players. But Josh Smith is better

the person above me says numbers dont lie and smith is better. if that is true numbers do lie. obviously wallace is better looking at the argument you just presented. wallace averages a double double.

Gerald Wallace, just look at his stats.

GERALD WALLACE 2009-10 Statistics. PPG: 18.3; RPG: 10.20; APG: 2.1; EFF: + 22.91.

JOSH SMITH 2009-10 Statistics. PPG: 15.8; RPG: 8.80; APG: 4.3; EFF: + 22.05

just look at the stats its defitinely gerald wallace

josh smith has only good dunks nothing else

Let's break down their numbers shall we?

Josh Smith's 2010 Stats:

PPG 15.7

RPG 8.7

APG 4.2

SPG 1.6

BPG 2.1

FG% .505

FT% .618

3P% .000

TPG 2.4

MPG 35.4

USG% 22.2

PER 21.0

TS% .536

eFG% .505

ORtg 109

DRtg 102

Gerald Wallace's 2010 stats

PPG 18.3

RPG 10.1

APG 2.1

SPG 1.5

BPG 1.1

FG% .483

FT% .773

3P% .371

TOV 2.3

MPG 41.3

USG% 20.2

PER 18.3

TS% .585

eFG% .511

ORtg 113

DRtg 100

Numbers don't lie. Josh Smith is the better player.