Payton Manning or Brett Favre?

Easily Peyton Manning. All you have to do is look at the averages.

Yards per attempt: Peyton has 7.7, Favre has 7.1

TD percentage: Peyton's is 5.6, Favre's is 5.1

INT percentage: Peyton's is 2.8, Favre's is 3.2

Completion %: Peyton's is 64.8, Favre's is 62.0

The only reason Favre has the records he does is because he's played for so long. While that durability helps his case, he still isn't as good as Peyton.

Peyton Manning.

Favre has been an exciting player over the years; but Manning is much better at protecting the football and managing the game. He will own all of Favre's records, except interceptions, before his career is over.

Having said that, it's difficult to chose based on playoff records. Favre is 13-11 in the postseason; Manning is 9-9.

Manning. Favre 10 years ago

Firsts of all (not being judgmental), it's Peyton Manning. Second of all, Peyton Manning. It's like when you put a football in his hand, he knows exactly what to do with. He's consistent. He stays in the pocket. He barely even gets touched. Favre is more of a move-all-around-the-place type of QB. That's why he keeps getting hit and injured. And if you even look at their stats, even though it's very close, Peyton Manning is better. I hope that his brother learns a thing or two from him.

for the past 4-5 years it's been peyton easy, but prime favre in his younger days > manning

Peyton Manning by a country mile.

Peyton. They both only won one superbowl so they doesnt seperate them but when it comes to play QB no IMO comes close to Manning

peyton manning

Manning is Boss

Farve is well....we all know his deal

Wait until both are finished.