Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

t asked in Family & RelationshipsFamily · 1 decade ago

I'm 31 and I hit my little brother he is 16? Did I go about this the wrong way?

My little brother is 16 the youngest child in our family of 8 and he is the most spoiled person ever. He literally is a bad kid and I tell him lots of times to stay out of trouble but he just won't listen to anyone but himself. So today he got in trouble at school today and my mother was fed up with it, he only lives with my mother because our dad is in the hospital sick and isn't home and all he does a is give our mom more trouble. So my mother called me to talk with him. So I did, i basically told him to stop being a brat and listen in school and start listening to our mom. He had a mouth on him and wasn't basically annoying me saying "yea." whatever and looking the other way. So i told him look at me when I'm talking and then he got to nerve to cuss at me, I got so angry with this kid. So I basically grabbed him and put him against the wall and I was scolding him. Then he hits me, So I hit him back, and then he says he calling the police. So I grab the phone out of his hand and told him to stop being immature and grow up. Then he leaves the room and slam his door, so I just left him alone. I don't mean to act like his dad or anything but he gives me no choice when he's being so stupid all the time. My other brothers and sisters won't even talk to him because they say they are tired of his disrespect but he won't disrespect or he will get dealt with. This happened yesterday so I was thinking maybe I could've been more calm about the situation.

8 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Well, that sounds like my older sister, and I'm one of those siblings that is just so tired of her. With what you said, I think that you did do the right thing. There just comes a point where you're just so tired of all the s*** that they give you and there's really no other way that you know of handling things. Honestly, I hope that I can do that to my own sister. I don't believe that you're in the wrong here. He's 16 and needs to grow up for he would soon be out in the real world where he'd either make it or suffer and go down a never ending abyss.

  • 1 decade ago

    Yes you did go about this the wrong way. You should NEVER EVER under ANY circumstances hit a minor. You could be and should be charged with assault. He does have the right to call the cops and have charges pressed on you. He also should not be "dealt with" you get more bees with honey than vinegar. You should talk to him calmly like an adult and try to get to the bottom of his reasons for being so disrespectful.

    sorry if I sound a bit mean but it's the truth

    Source(s): I am 16 and even I know how to handle my anger better than that.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    You did the right thing he is being a brat and needs disciplined there is no father figure there for him and he is disrespecting your mum,Your mum obviously is stressed over this which is why she called you to talk to him and he didn't listen to you and you lashed out,Now he is playing the old child abuse I'm calling the cops crap,I have a sister the same age and it must be just the age they are at that rebellious teenage cheekyness she rolled her eyes at me once when I asked her a simple question,I responded with "DON'T YOU EVER F'ING ROLL YOUR EYES AT ME AGAIN" She got scared and new never to be cheeky or rude around me again,A bit of discipline and showing them your no push over keeps them in line,It also turns them into respectable kids,Keep an eye on him and tell him off when he is doing wrong

  • 1 decade ago

    Honestly it's up to the parent to hit the child. You are doing wrong, but if I was in the same situation I probably would have hit him too. A person who is acting like a child, that is seriously spoiled sometimes needs to be hit. You should have asked your mother to do it. I'd apologies to your little brother, and explain why you hit him. Maybe he will grow up a bit.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Why should he respect you, he is a 16 year old teenager and your a 31 year old man and you hit him.

    You have to earn respect not just expect it because your older than him.

    You are his BROTHER not his Dad. You have to start acting like his brother and not his dad. What were you and your siblings like at this age? Surely you werent perfect. you need to sit down and have a chat with him, not lecture him, that will just cause conflict and make him disrespect you even more.

  • 1 decade ago

    Maybe your approaching this problem wrong! Instead of condemning him, with negativity, and instead of scolding him like a small child, try to find out what is bothering him to make him act out like he is doing. Try to sit him down, and just ask him what is going on in his head, and in his life, what is troubling him? Talk calm, and Man to Man!

    I am only saying this, because 25 years ago I was a teenager who was acting out, and instead of my parents, siting down and just asking what was wrong, they ignored me, and just acted mean, like I was a trouble maker. I was just feeling unloved by them, and they just confirmed it for me, by reacting like they did. It has left many scars, and I can still feel the pain 25 years later!

  • 1 decade ago

    all you need need to do is show your dominance, and that your the pack leader, what you have told everyone is full of negative energy, maybe sometimes you should nip him on the neck to show dominance, try not hurt the child as that will give negative energy, making a PSST noise that the same time helps in many ways too.

  • 1 decade ago

    violence is not the answer, in most cases, but YOU DID THE RIGHT THING.

    YOU SHOULDA WHOOPED HIS A$$ MORE.

    dam spoiled kids

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.