Whos better Morneau or Ortiz?

Morneau is productive and hits for average. I'd take him over a fat, slow, 'roid user Ortiz anyday.

Morneau

Morneau Ortiz is already old, slow, not as good as he was in 04, so Morneau is definitely the better player.

Morneau won the AL MVP without steroids and he is a reliable 30 HR, 100 RBI guy every year. Ortiz is not even that good. He just had a couple seasons where he hit 50 HR but was also on roids.

Justin Morneau is EASILY the better player of the two. David Ortiz isn't the scary player he once was when he was on the roids. He's been exposed already.

At this point, it's not even debatable. Morneau is the better player.

I guess Morneau is more of complete player than big papi, but big papi is a Yankee killer and so from my side of it, Ortiz is better. but Morneau is the more complete player.

Marneau is better overall, he is a good fielder and can run a little better than Ortiz. However he's hurt right now and riding the pine, so today Ortiz is better.

'Big Papi' Oritz