Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Lovey
Lv 5
Lovey asked in Family & RelationshipsFriends · 1 decade ago

My good friend abuses his girlfriend...?

I was friends with "Dana and Chuck" for about 7 years. Saw them fall in love, marry, have three children and divorce. It turns out that Dana's time in the foster care system had done a number on her. It slowly dawned on Chuck (and slower on me) that she was an adulterous chameleon. She cheated MANY times with ANYONE, had a child outside of their marriage, lied daily, taught her children to lie, and would basically blend in with ANYONE she was around no matter how she felt about them. She was a mess. Chuck and I were shocked to realize that we didn't know her at all because she has an amazing ability to behave in any way that is conducive to getting what she wants. After they split, she had a parade of boyfriends she referred to as "daddy" when speaking to the kids, continued to lie about numerous things, had some legal problems, neglected the children, and put them in dangerous situations. It was all very difficult to watch- even as a friend. Eventually, I had to stop spending time with Dana, but continued my friendship with Chuck.

Chuck has custody of the youngest child- the only one who is biologically his. He's a sensitive, artistic, funny, and intelligent man who is from an alcoholic and abusive home. He has a new girlfriend, "Sadie." Sadie is a good woman with a good head on her shoulders. She really loves Chuck and his child. She's been a mother to his child for three years now. In the past 9 months, Chuck has beaten Sadie twice. Once, he forced her into the vehicle, took her into the country and kicked her repeatedly. He also threatened to drive off a bridge with her and used an awful lot of force to keep her in the vehicle. Another time, he's body slammed her and beat her. I've NEVER KNOWN him to be abusive and I've been good friends with him for 10 years now (7years with his wife, three years with Sadie.) Still, I'm not shocked hearing this today. He's still very angry at Dana, but doesn't deal with it. Instead, he just refuses to talk about her. In the heat of the moment, he told Sadie to leave, and when she packed her things, Chuck's child packed also, saying "I'm going with Mommy." Chuck threatened that if Sadie took the child, he'd have her charged with kidnapping. He promised both times to get help, but has sense refused and becomes very angry when it's brought up.

Sadie is stuck in between a rock and a hard place. The child already has abandonment issues because of Dana. Sadie has been a real mother to this child. A lawyer has told Sadie she has absolutely no parental rights. Sadie has no income and is a stay at home mother. Chuck has been isolating her lately, and she doesn't have much access to a car. She loves Chuck and doesn't want to hurt him, but she wants to leave. What is the best thing for her to do? What is the best thing for Chuck? If Sadie leaves and turns him in, the child will go to Dana- which is a really bad place for a child. Of course, an abusive home is a really bad place too. I told Sadie to organize an intervention for Chuck asking him to get help; naming consequences if he refuses, but offering support if he accepts. Other than that, I'm at a loss and so is Sadie. I love them all. I'm usually cut and dry about an abuser wanting the abused to leave and the abuser to suffer consequences, but this situation is sticky. Finally, I see the abuser as a real person who is actually good. I used to think that sounded ridiculous when others would say it, but I've known him for a third of my life and he IS good. Help.

3 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    Forcible beatings...With a situation like this, despite how friendly he may seem, force is going to be necessary..If he doesn't want to face what's bothering him, then it's only going to bother him more & cause more trouble down the road...If Sadie does organize an intervention, you should definitely be there as support too, for being in a group brings strength..It sounds like the best thing to do, for you don't want the child to end up at an abusive home, but if he won't accept help then it really is best for Sadie to leave...There's no reason for her to be receiving abuse for Chuck's anger, & if he won't face what's bothering him, it's not right for her to get the end of it...

  • 1 decade ago

    What a tragic situation! If Sadie leaves, the kid is likely to be battered . Foster care for the kid might have to be the best compromise. Sadie needs to leave before worse happens to her. There are battered women's shelters. It might be best for the kid if Sadie took the child too to a battered women's shelter and get their help to sort things out. Even the kid goes to foster care, the child will know that Sadie did not leave her with the Dad. They have any Native American Indian blood? If is certain percentage can live on reservation.

    This situation sounds bad enough that someone could die from battering or suicide. You, the writer, could be in danger too. If Sadie disappears, will he hound you? Don't know if any of you folks go to church? Could have folks praying for you? OR could be demons involved, get an exorcist for Chuck?

    Anyway, would be great if Sadie and Kid could just disappear into a better life. There are children's advocacy groups too, The child is in a dangerous situation, especially if Sadie leaves, and especially since the kid has displayed "disloyalty" to the father by threatening to leave with step mom.

    Obviously, Chuck is mentally ill. Sadie needs to have established a legal record of abuse, police, paramedics, doctors verify her injuries and dates of them. Might be able to haul Chuck off for assault or something. If there are records showing abuse, then if Sadie leaves taking the child, she will have a better standing by the law. If Sadie could be foster mom to kid? Biological mom might give rights or have a file of evidence against her as to her ability to provide a safe home for a child.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    whenever i submit a question, even if it is the simplest one, nobody can offer me a proper informed answer on this website. Wtf happened to people that actually make the effort to answer?

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.