Deathly Hallows DISAPPOINTED me......PLEASE READ THIS...?

Question

Well, i have absolutely no complaints of what was shown in the movie. It rocked and it was awesome...but here are a few points that all of us had expcted to see in part 1 a these were in early pages which were surely covered in first part of the movie;

1.When Harry goes to Umbridge's office, he sees Mad-Eye's magical eye fixed at the door. In the book, Harry steals the eye from her office and buries it properly but no scene related to this was  there in the movie

2.Dumbledore's past which was so important and interesting was just covered in 2 or 3 lines by Elphias Dodge and Aunt Muil during the wedding. There was no discussion of Ariana,Percival and Kendara Dumbledore which was long-windedly explained in the book.

3.When they go to the Godric's hollow, Dumbledore's parents' grave upposed to be right next to the Potter's but there was no sign of it.

4.After seeing the graves of his parents. Harry meets the Fake Bathilda Bagshot then she takes him to her house. Here, acc.to the book Voldemort was suppose to come to make an unsuccessful attempt to kill Harry but this scene was cut too.

5.Remus Lupin was suppose to come to Grimmaud's place and then there was a small duel of words b/w him and Harry but Lupin was never shown in th movie except for the very first or second scene.

6.Acc. to the book, Hermione steals Phineas's portrait from grimmaud's place and somewhere in their long journey she asks him to bring Dumbledore to his portrait.

7.How can we forget such an important part, Harry finds half torn letter written by his mother in Sirius' room but again no scene like this was aired.


Overall, I can say that it was a very nice movie but even though it has been split into two parts, then also they have not been able to cover all the parts........What do you people think.....

deelenapowers · Accepted Answer

I was very, very disappointed in this movie.  You would think that if they felt the need to make 2 parts to try to get more of the story in, they would actually put more of the story in.  They left out too many defining parts of the books and put meaningless stuff in.  You don't get the emotional impact of the story because too much back log from the book has been left out.  I am so sad for everyone who like me  love the books.  I felt like i was watching a cheap knock off of the book instead of a movie with the book as a foundation.  I really felt bad for those who have not read the books.  It seemed to me that you would be lost if you didn't already know the book.  My personal opinion is to spend your money on the Audio books by Jim Dale as they are far and away better than the movies, especially this one!
DeeLena

NuckenFutz · Answer

I too was very disappointed. Once I saw a commercial about the movie I watched all the movies over, had very high expectations for the movie and then I read the book some and I got to like page 124 and when I saw all of those parts in the movie I was very disappointed. They cut out so much stuff it is horrible. I was angry at myself because I didn't like the movie because I liked all the other ones but I also hate when a movie continues (ex. Part 1 And Part 2) I hate that. It might be because I read the book, it might be because I have never had a movie change so much. IDK i really didn't like it though

Anonymous · Answer

I wanted to see Poge Dog Breath. Then they did not show Wormtail strangle himself. Luna's room, I really wanted to see that. Luna's fly swatting dance at the wedding. Then Voldy fly in when Nagini attacks them and the breaking of the wand. Yeah the torn picture in Sirius's room. Then George lose his ear.

:D · Answer

well i'm going to see the movie today at 4. so i don't know yet but i have big expectations since the book was good

Trending News

Deathly Hallows DISAPPOINTED me......PLEASE READ THIS...?

4 Answers