Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 5
? asked in TravelAfrica & Middle EastEgypt · 1 decade ago

Egypt: Will an Egyptian explain this for me in Arabic please?

This is verrryyyy tricky, so bear with me here.

Someone at school brought up a very interesting topic today. He said Israeli rabbis allow Jewish men and women to sleep with non Jewish people if it's for the benefit of the country or the religion without it being a sin, an example being a spy working in enemy territory.

He also said that Israeli opposition leader Tzipi Livni was one of those who underwent all that when she used to work as an agent in the Mossad.

I guess I was kinda intrigued by this, where do you think Islam stands on this? and if serving the country forces you to go through with it, would you?! It's so confusing!!! :S

9 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    No tab3an ! there's nothing like that in Islam...there's Hadith but i don't remember it all,bs ma m3nah " en el mar2a lw a6a3et rabena we a6a3et zogha we 3amalet el forood ely 3aleha we 7afazet nafsaha..da yo3adel el gehaad fe sabeel ellah !!!...y3ny rabena haydeha nafs el thawab we hya fe betha we m7afza 3ala nafsaha.....da "ely ymoot we hwa bydafe3 3an 3ardo,yb2a shaheed"..yb2a mneen b2a el Islam haysm7 be 7aga zy de?..madam rabena 7arram el zena,yb2a maynf3sh yb2a 7alal fe case we case tanya l2..7aram y3ny 7aram !there's no exceptions..and of course for Men tab3an kaman msh women bs.

  • 1 decade ago

    No Islam refuses this kind of "dirty" tricks, like if you see any Egyptian espionage movies or soap operas you'd find the lead character trying to throw away any alcohol served to him or ditching a girl trying a move on him,so that means that actually these guys refused any such advances that would affect their religious beliefs,even though trickery is accepted in fighting the enemy in Islam but the red-lines should never be crossed as long as you can without blowing your cover.

  • ?
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    Tsk tsk. "if serving the country forces you to go through it, would you?" No. I'm totally against that religion comes first & like comitting premarital relations for the benefit of my country and not considering that a SIN, da eih el estehbal da, some of em jews would prolly be against it saying "nah we shall not sleep with the enemy for the benefit of Israel" but "sleeping with the enemy" is not even the issue, it's actually having em typa relations with anyone PERIOD.

    I actually heard that apparently some female spies that worked for the Egyptian intelligence agency were involved in similar acts like gettin what they have to via sleeping with Israeli officials, agents etc. I was soo shocked like masreyeen doing that are you serious? If that's true, how disappointing. It's your duty to be able to defend your country and strive for it's benefit when you can, which in their case involves finding and transmitting certain info and it's a risky process.. bas kolou ella da! demeaning & lowering yourself like that, it's like you transition from being a human to a dog, where does your instinct of self-worth, respect and dignity come in? I think one should use his intelligence in such cases, not his sexuality, that's just takin the easy and not to mention filthy way out of things, whatta frikkin cheap shot. Anyways typical jewish tactics what I can say..

  • ?
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    In my opinion yan3y whatever you're trying to decide whether it's haram or halal you take it to el Quraan wel Sunna, then you ask ahl el3elm we fel a5er betsatafty kalbak (dah in general) in that case specifically, hao mafeesh taree2a tania to serve your country 3'er beeha? have you tried your best to serve your country in every possible way we bardo mafeesh 3'er deh?.....I'm not gonna say haram wala halal coz frankly I don't know (though I'm more inclined eno haram) but IMO this is how you should think anything through men ne7yet el 7ormania ya3ny.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • Passio
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Eh el neswan dy elly bet wasa5 nafsaha 3ashan ba3den ye ro7o ye2telo 3arab ma3amalush 7aga??

  • G. #2
    Lv 7
    1 decade ago

    I don't know about Zibbi Livni, but the first paragraph is true, I knew that before.

    As for Islam. la2 tab3a mayenfa3sh, are you seriously asking this question?? O_o

  • ?
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    No, Islam wouldn't allow such actions aslan whether its to serve the country or not. there are other Islam-safe ways to serve the country msh lazem el zena wl 7agat el tania de or muslim women posing as non muslims (taking off their hijab and whatnot)

  • 1 decade ago

    look the problem with judaism is that it's not from God anymore it's from the rabbis, & it has been like that since the babylonians captured the people of judah.

    Islam is on its way to be from the emams as well, (well shia islam IS), so we should stand up against this.

    as for your question, as far as i know, it's haram.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Allahu A3lam but i think it is 7aram IN ALL CASES

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.