Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Free Will & God knowing the future...?
My question is if God know the future, then do you still have free will?
Ex: God knows I'm going to hit a dog with my car next Tuesday. I choose to swerve & miss the dog. God already knows that I'm supposed to hit the dog with my car. So by swerving out of the way, haven't I just proven God wrong who is supposed to be infallible?
The point of the question is that if God knows the future, then you don't have free will. It's called fatalism.
11 Answers
- jeanvaljean1970Lv 41 decade agoFavorite Answer
Precisely. Why do people pray? Can god change his mind?
- hillbillyLv 71 decade ago
You still have free will. God knows that you will approach a dog with your car next Tuesday, but He also knows that you will choose to swerve and miss the dog (or try to anyhow), or maybe He knows that you will approach the dog and NOT swerve or miss it, which ever happens. God doesn't often step in and change things against free will. God bless.
- LindaLouLv 71 decade ago
How you & I see or understand God's all knowingness is NOT how GOD sees it. God sees all things in a total eternal continuum not like we do. I might know what my children will choose because I know them so well. God on the other hand sees the whole of our lives and choices fully & completely. He would have already known you had swerved to miss the dog too... You fail to understand the depth of God's omnipotence and nature it seems to me. He doesn't make the choices for us - since we are finite creatures we always have the choice. HE being an infinite, eternal and perfected holy BEING isn't confined to the finite and narrow constraints that we are.
HE knows all things because of who HE IS. Likewise we are free to choose because of WHO we are in this mortal existence.
- SolarLv 61 decade ago
Just because He knows something will happen doesn't make Him the cause of the happening.
Like my favorite football team has a lot of injuries and they were going up against a great opponent. I knew they were going to lose. And I was right. They still had free will and played the game. My knowing the outcome had no bearing on how they performed (pitifully to say the best).
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- lindaLv 51 decade ago
Although God has the ability to look into the future he does not always use it. Neither does he predetermine our lives and everything that will happen in our lives. That is why he gives us free will. He allows us to make our own choices in life.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
God knows the choices you will make. If God KNOWS you ran over a dog, then you will make the choices that cause that to happen....His knowing is a consequences of the choices you will make. The reality you carve by your choices
His knowlege does not mold your choices
This question is the the product of limited thinking.
- neil sLv 71 decade ago
The standard argument, already used here, is that God's knowledge of what you will do does not make you do it. This argument only works if God is not your creator. In other words, it's utter nonsense.
- Anonymous1 decade ago
You can swerve but if your meant to hit the dog, you're going to hit the dog.