Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

How essential is the "Album Experience"?

When you try and hear as much music as I and many people here do, I think there is the temptation to just hear a few of the "higher rated" songs from certain "less important" albums and then move ahead to something else. I have done this and thought I could judge the whole album based on them. Perhaps I sometimes can, but I've been thinking this is perhaps a less fulfilling way of music listening.

I'm certainly missing some of the context of the albums I do this with, and the context has varying degrees of importance depending on the album... but there's just too many albums to listen to. But what do you think, do you do this with some albums? Has the internet-given ability to pick and choose what tracks we get taken away from the "Album Experience", or is it good that we are now able to skip by all the "fluff" and get to the good stuff?

BQ: Favorite album that works best as a whole?

BQ2: Favorite album that has a bunch of great songs that don't need the context of the full "album experience" to be great?

Update:

@ captain: Yeah, that's why I put those terms in quotations. It really is flawed, but I have at times just gone for tracks that allmusic or this other music writer I like, George Starostin, have highlighted as the "best tracks", due to me not having the patience to sit through all the albums of a given band.

9 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    That's the way I've been with albums my whole life. I was dedicated at wearing out rewind and fast-forward buttons back in the day. With me it is a VERY rare occasion when I like every song on an album. Out of the probably 5000 albums I like do you know how many I could name that I like every single song from? Probably 50-100. Most albums I like between two and three songs from and the rest I could care less if I ever heard again. With me it's not about the album, or context or any of that, it's about what pleases my ears. And most songs often don't. When I get a new album I generally pick up on the two or three good/unique tracks pretty quick and chuck the rest. I mean why on earth would I ever want to spend another second listening to a song I don't want to hear? Life is too short for Bull****, let's let the rubber meet the road and rock. And to hell with all the extraneous puff. What you call the "full album experience" is a rare rare thing for me.

    BA: A few I can enjoy hearing as a whole

    Evolution by Journey

    Dark Side of the Moon by Pink Floyd

    Houses of the Holy by Led Zeppelin

    Close To the Edge by Yes

    BA: a couple of collections of great stand alone songs that happen to be albums

    Sticky Fingers by The Stones

    Endless Skies by Ashbury

    Deep Purple In Rock

    Powerage by AC/DC

  • 1 decade ago

    Honestly, I've discovered that the higher rated or more listened to songs of a band (for example, the songs that get really popular and play on the radio all day) are often the worst songs that artist has ever put out, and it escapes me how it becomes so popular. Songs like Scream by Avenged Sevenfold, which is an awful song, plays on the radio while some of their much better songs are never even considered. I dont understand it. You really do have to listen to the whole album, because most people have terrible taste in music and make the worst songs popular

  • 1 decade ago

    how do you know it's fluff if you don't listen to it?

    whose judgement are you trusting re. 'higher rated' and 'less important' ?

    thank goodness we haven't reached the stage yet where bands think: 'we won't bother with an album, lets just release one song every month' (go on, tell me that's been done already...)

    i can understand the position of 'i only like one song' if you've taken the time to listen to more, but a habit of just listening to a couple of tracks just to tick the 'heard them' box is pretty shallow.

    ba: the blurred crusade - the church

    ba2: any 'greatest hits' album

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    I feel it's mainly necessary for concept albums that revolve around a theme and transition from one song to another. But, it's not totally needed for other albums. I, however, choose to listen to all albums front-to-back because it's definitely a different experience from just choosing singles.

    BQ: 'Black Saint and the Sinner Lady' by Charles Mingus

    BQ2: 'Paid in Full' by Eric B. and Rakim

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • ?
    Lv 4
    1 decade ago

    I only skip the songs ive already listened to be determined as fluff from me. Ill skip the song halfway through too just if its not cutting it for me. But i have to listen throughout the album to actually get an opinion.

    BQ: any prog rock album

    BQ2: i cant think at the moment.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    to a purist, or someone that grew up in the age of the album the album experience is very important. back in the olden days when we had turntables it was a little harder to skip over songs, at least until cassettes came along.

    as you stated, technology has advanced so now you can skip, delete, and rearrange the order of songs on albums. in many ways technology has brought us back to the age of the single, and i don't think many people are as into the album experience as in the past.

  • BQ) Nostradamus by Judas Priest.

    It's essential to listen to listen to all its tracks in a serial order because every song is a continuation of the other. It's just like one big song.

  • .
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    To put it this way, I usually listen to albums all the way through in order

  • 1 decade ago

    Not really all that important to me.

    BQ: A Fever You Can't Sweat Out - Panic! At The Disco

    BQ2: Take Off Your Colours - You Me At Six

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.