Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Looking for advice on how to deal with hoarders?

Here's the situation. Some fifteen years ago my aunt moved from another state to the town where our whole family lives. This aunt was a GIGANTIC shopaholic, buying purses off of QVC, cheap plastic made in China junk from dollar stores, books on secret methods of winning the lottery, VCR cassette rewinders shaped like pink Cadillacs, and the like, and she wouldn't buy just one, she'd buy five or six of these things. Her stuff wouldn't fit into her new apartment so it was stockpiled elsewhere all over the place, including a spare room of mine. There was so much junk it was literally piled to the ceiling. My other aunt (her sister) who I rent my house from, kept saying over and over that she was going to come by and sort these items out, but never did. This is because she had no room for this stuff- her two car garage was so filled with stuff from other people that she has to park her car outside. I was told her basement was chock full of stuff too.

Fast forward to today. My shopoholic aunt died and this junk hasn't been touched or even looked at in years. My mother's place is now being refurbished and she needs to live with me for a few months, so I cleaned 3/4 of this junk out. I donated the good stuff to church auctions, threw the cheap plastic junk away, threw away bags and bags and bags of clothes and left the remaining items that looked to have some value for my other aunt (who never showed up to look through this stuff) to claim. I even kept a sample of the junk we threw away (consisting of an unused in the box plastic recipe card holder you put on refrigerators, an unused in the package plastic pill cutter, an unused in the box penlight, and an unused in the package miniature ironing board. I think I left a tax code book from 1989 too, I forget.

When my aunt came by last night to see what I've done, she became absolutely livid. She threw a temper tantrum and was sobbing literally in tears on how dare I throw out her belongings, how she can't trust anyone anymore and how badly I let her down, and demanded I make a list of EVERYTHING I threw out. Clothes, receipts from Australian lotteries, fake collapsible Christmas trees, pots and pans, everything. I even asked her if she HONESTLY wanted a still in the package plastic pill cutter that my other aunt never even used and she snarled yes. She was yelling how dare I give a clock away to my brother because "she might have wanted to give it to someone" which makes zero sense to me. She cradled the small pile of pill cutter/recipe holder/pen light/whatever, like they were some valuable rare antiques and jumped in her car crying. She drove ten feet, put in into reverse, drove back to where I was standing, and yelled once more that I make a list of everything I got rid of, and drove off. I called my mother to let her know what happened so she'll call her to smooth things out.

I don't know how to handle this. Everyone else in the family I talked to about this concurs that my aunt isn't upset over my throwing out anything valuable or that she has sentimental attachment to this stuff, because let's face it, if she has emotional attachment to a cheap plastic pill cutter that noone ever used then she's got a screw loose. Everyone occurs that she wanted this junk becuase she wants to hoard this sh*t. She grew up durning the depression when people had to learn to make do with what they had so she'll see even the most worthless POS valuable. It's my position that she if she wanted any of this stuff she would have come by sometime within the last TEN YEARS to come get it, and lets's face it, if there really was anything genuinely valuable in this pile she would have magically found room for it at her house regardless of how filled up it was. I even made a conscious attempt to keep anything that looked valuable or sentimental for her. It was my obligation to make my place a clean, safe place for my mother to live, and now my aunt is all but demanding that my mother needs to live in the middle of a junk pile.

Any advice would be appreciated right now. How do I deal with a ninety year old hoarder, 'cause right now I feel like a jerk from having to ask my brother for the clock back. Incredible. Absolutely incredible.

7 Answers

Relevance
  • 1 decade ago
    Favorite Answer

    I have heard that people who hoard have psychological issues. That being said the only way to help to for a person to have therapy. I personally that that some people who are labeled as hoarders aren't necessary hoarders, just lazy. But in your case, it sounds like a hoarder. There's really not much that you can do to change the persons mind, they believe that everything or anything is valuable and don't understand why they should get rid of some things. In fact there's a show on cable called Hoarders and it's absolutely astonishing what people keep and how they live among it. If I were you I wouldn't even ask for the clock back, it's gone. I wouldn't even bother to make a list. She's a little out there and she's just going to be mad anyway. I would just apologize to her, gather it all up and take it to her home, (if possible). I think that it was very kind of you to go through the stuff and try to keep some of the things, because I would have pitched it all. I can't stand clutter or junk around. Less is more to me.

  • Anonymous
    5 years ago

    I can completely relate to you, my mother has always been a hoarder. My entire childhood-teen years I couldn't have any friends over. My mom would flip out if I tried throwing her stuff out or cleaning. It can be extremely tough dealing with a hoarding mom, I am 23 years old now and live with my boyfriend. He complains that I am messy, I believe that a lot of my mom's hoarding habits have rubbed off on me. It sucks big time, I am really embarrassed by it. I think, in the mean time, just be sure to keep your space clean (your bedroom and whatnot).Clean what you can. It's a good thing that you are noticing your moms hoarding is an issue early on that way it will be a less chance that it rubs off on you once you move out on your own.

  • 5 years ago

    I am dealing with a male room mate who has hoarded everything for the past 7-8 years. His room consists of two avalanches, one from each wall. He now has stored a bicycle which he screw a drugee out of, behind the sofa in the living room. That goes today!! If there isn't room for storage in your own room.....rent a storage unit ot throw it out. Changes in the old homestead start to happen today.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Make the stupid list,

    give her the junk,

    and don't take any junk from her, even if she begs.

    Just get it over with, if she has a problem, only she can want to get rid of it, and will ask help,

    but don't allow her to make you fuel her problem.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 6 years ago

    Tell her, it's done. If that stuff was important to you, surely you can make the list. Brother has the clock and sends his thank you to you for it. THE END

  • 1 decade ago

    WAY too long a question. - I didn't read it

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    too much drama

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.