Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

BlueThunder asked in SportsHockey · 10 years ago

What NHL division realignment would you suggest when Winnipeg gets Atlanta's team?

Winnipeg hockey fans will happy to have a team again and really won't care that much which division the team plays in. There isn't a requirement for any realignment but you'd think the league will eventually do one of sorts since Winnipeg being in the Southeast Division isn't a very good fit.

What division realignment would you suggest the NHL do?

11 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    10 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    From what I understand next year they will not align and the Southeast will contain Winnipeg in it.

    However when they do align (eventually) I think they should do the following:

    Northeast:

    Boston

    Montreal

    Toronto

    Buffalo

    Ottawa

    Atlantic:

    Philadelphia

    New Jersey

    New York Rangers

    New York Islanders

    Pittsburgh

    Southeast:

    Washington

    Nashville (New)

    Florida

    Tampa Bay

    Carolina

    Central:

    Detroit

    Chicago

    Columbus

    St. Louis

    Dallas (New)

    Northwest:

    Minnesota

    Vancouver

    Winnipeg (New)

    Calgary

    Edmonton

    Pacific:

    San Jose

    Los Angeles

    Anaheim

    Phoenix

    Colorado (New)

  • 10 years ago

    Easiest and less troublesome. Winnipeg into Northwest pushing Colorado to the Central pushing Nashville to the Southeast.

    Yes Detroit and Columbus are further east than Nashville but Nashville is further south. Minnesota is a geographical rival for Winnipeg, more so than Colorado. But I'm ambivalent on this move.

    Yes I'd love to see Detroit in the east and Bettman owes Illitch a favour but the Chicago / St. Louis influence will stop that logic from occurring.

    But there will be no logic in the realignment particularly when Columbus and Phoenix will be moving next year (after next lockout).

  • Anonymous
    10 years ago

    Nashville will move to the Southeast based on it being the least amount of disruption(at least in the Eastern Conference) The East is set up to be the easiest on travel time and costs for their divisions as well as rivalries. Since it was asked why they'd be the ones moved. I think the first answer has it right. The West is just too spread out to be set up the way the East is so they are going to be the Conference that is adjusted more off of it. Since the Southeast is already so spread out(for the Eastern Conference) adding Nashville really won't be a big deal. Putting Columbus in the Southeast just wouldn't make much sense(and likely keeping Nashville would add more travel time to the West) and moving Detroit would REALLY make no sense over Columbus.

  • 10 years ago

    Basically the league would have to make 3 moves for relocation.

    Winnipeg would go to the Northwest and join Vancouver/Edmonton/Calgary/Colorodo

    Minnesota would go to the Central and join Detroit/Chicago/Columbus/ St. Louis

    Nashville would switch Conference and join the Southeast conference with Washington/Tampa Bay/Florida/Carolina.

    Geographically speaking this makes the most sense... Also, it would cut travel costs down for Nashville as they won't have to travel nearly as many miles as they currently do. The move also benefits Minnesota for the same reason.

    Winnipeg in the Northwest would be four canadian teams in the division all within relative proximity to each other.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 10 years ago

    Once it comes time for the divisions to be realigned, I suggest the following:

    Winnipeg to Northwest

    Colorado to Pacific

    Dallas to Central

    Detroit to Northeast

    Boston to Atlantic

    Philadelphia to Southeast

  • 10 years ago

    Smythe Division

    Calgary Flames

    Edmonton Oilers

    Los Angeles Kings

    Vancouver Canucks

    Winnipeg Jets

  • mega
    Lv 6
    10 years ago

    I like Captain Percocet's realignment plan. I might also throw out there putting Vancouver in the Pacific Division instead of Colorado if keeping all four Canadian teams in the West in one division is not strictly necessary.

  • Captain Percocet's idea makes a lot of sense for both conferences. Yes, Nashville is west of Detroit and Columbus, but further south. And having Detroit change conferences would wreck a lot of rivalries they've built up over the years.

    And this would also make the Baltimore Classic in September between Nashville and Washington a lot more fun.

  • Next year won't see any re-alignment.

    For 2012-13 and beyond...put Nashville in the Southeast, put WPG in the Northwest, bump Denver out of the Northwest and into the Pacific, and bump Dallas into the Central. It would look like this:

    NE: TOR, OTT, BUF, BOS, MTL

    ATL: PIT, PHL, NYI, NYR, NJD

    SE: FLA, TBL, CAR, WSH, NSH

    NW: WPG, MIN, CGY, VAN, EDM

    PAC: SJS, LAK, ANA, PHX, COL

    CEN: DAL, DET, STL, CBJ, CHI

    Rationale:

    NSH: Help Nashville by giving them multiple visits from big-market eastern conf. teams (in turn for losing games against DET and CHI)

    WPG: Give Winnipeg multiple all-Canadian games which helps TSN/CBC/RDS.

    COL: Give Pacific time teams a break from having to travel across two time zones for divisional play (Pacific/Mountain).

    DAL: Ease of travel burden, only one time zone separates entire division.

    Under this plan all divisions are no more than one time zone apart.

  • 10 years ago

    i think it should be based on time zones when it comes to the west

    1. north east

    buffalo

    montreal

    ottawa

    toronto

    boston

    2. atlantic

    rangers

    islanders

    flyers

    pens

    devils

    3. southeast

    carolina

    washington

    tampa

    florida

    dallas

    4.central...same

    5.pacific

    sharks

    ducks

    nucks

    coyotes

    kings

    northeast

    flames

    oilers

    avs

    wild

    winnpeg

    this would make the most sense due to the fact that vancouver and all the pacific team are on the same time zone so travel would be less hectic..and dallas wouldnt have to travel as far to play its divisional games by having florida tampa and carolina in their division the time change is only 1 hour

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.