Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Karn Liberated question.?
Opponent casts Karn the planeswalker. plays the -4 ability that exiles a target creature, can i respond to it by playing a spell or an ability that sacrifices target creature to fizzle his target? like
1. karn targets vampire hexmage, i sac hexmage. what happends?
2. karn targets some creature, i respond by playing momentous fall. what happends?
thanks in advance
it's magic the gathering.,
uhm i thought PLaneswalkers did have priorities on their abilities.
thought on the priority please. thanks
like say, karn exiles my creature. i cast into the roil targetting karn. can karn still exile my creature? or I was able to roil him first
4 Answers
- 10 years agoFavorite Answer
Karn is moving at sorcery speed during a main phase and anything that you do at instant speed is going on the stack. So it should look a lot like this:
Karn Targets Vampire Hexmage to Exile
Priority changes to Hexmage Controller
Controller uses an instant that targets Hexmage to destroy/sacrifice
Priority changes to Karn Controller
Anything at Instant speed(Negate/Cancel/etc. to stop that reaction).
If no Response then stack empties with last response with a legal target as it's first execution then if that sacrifice/destroy goes through on the Hexmage then Karn has no legal target and his ability will still get it's loyalty counters because it was executed with a legal target but the target was taken away.
Short Answer: Yes you can use Instants/Abilities that run at instant speed to destroy the target of Karn's ability. But it will still get the loyalty counters for executing the ability.
Source(s): DCI Judge - shyvurboieLv 410 years ago
After your opponent activates the ability, yes, you're allowed to respond before it resolves. Getting rid of the target will counter the ability, because if all of a spell/ability's targets are illegal when it comes time for it to resolve, it gets countered by the rules. Getting rid of Karn won't do anything to help you, because it doesn't change the fact that the ability your opponent activated is still on the stack and will resolve when it comes time for it to do so.
Mike
Source(s): DCI-certified Rules Advisor