Searching for a movie with the same plot as Beastly?

My daughter sat down and watched Beastly together a few nights ago, and from the beginning we both swore we had already seen it. I realize that it was a new dvd release. and we did not see it in the theater. I think we may have seen another movie that was real similar to it. It would have had a disfigured young man who finally lets the girl he likes see his face, can't remember the whole story,

or the name. It's not Powder. Any movie geeks out there?