Do you think Robert Harvey should coach St Kilda next year?

Yes.

My guess is yes...because St Kilda was advertising for a new head of sports science and fitness preparation in last week's papers. Surely they wouldn't do this until a new coach was consulted...so my feeling is the Robert H has already started the process of appointing his own support team.

Gee champion players rarely make champion coaches unless they've played or worked under one for a long time. Saints haven't had too many winning coaches for him to learn from. They would have done well to grab a guy like Sanderson.

On the other hand I have no time for Lyon's tactics so maybe a more attacking style could be good.

Overall though, there's something about him that just doesn't strike me as coach material.

So, No.

No, they should go with Leon Cameron or maybe Mark Harvey. If they go with an inexperienced coach with their list it could bite them on the ar$e, Cameron has more experience than R Harvey, he's been an assistant for years.

No.

Robert Harvey may have been a good footballer but that doesn't make him a good coach. Have you heard him talk? He can hardly pronounce words with more than one syllable. All the better coaches have a bit of charisma and gift of the gab. Harvey has neither.

Probably yes....but it will be a very difficult position. He knows most of the players and is probably friendly with them. So it can also work against him.

But as he served his 2 years as an assistant, I think he's ready.

i sure hope so