Should I do this trade?

Question

I get:
Philip Rivers
Rashard Mendenhall

I give:
Matt Schaub
Beanie Wells

Beanie Wells is my backup RB (my starters are Adrian Peterson and Lesean McCoy) and Matt Schaub is my starting QB. My backup QB is Tony Romo.

wiczyman · Accepted Answer

Well I think you improve your starting lineup for the year by adding Rivers, who should be poised for a huge rest of the year after his typical slow start.

You're getting the best player in the deal which is always good but you're paying a high price for it.  If you're not turning the other team into a powerhouse then I would go ahead with it.

? · Answer

I wouldn't do it...after the bye week Romo will be 100% and isn't mcuh worse than Rivers. AndWells looked good last week, i watched the game, and Mendenhall is a bust so far, and if Redman keeps rolling he will be a bust for the season.

BTW, right now Romo is your starter and Schaub is the backup...with Johnson out at least...after he comes back, play the matchups.

Maria · Answer

I would not do this trade with Tony Romo  being on your bench.  You should be starting him every week.  The bigger question is why you are starting  Scaubb over Romo????  You RB position gets weaker. Mendenhall is a bust.

Anonymous · Answer

I think Philip Rivers is going to have a MONSTER game. But Mendenhall is gimpy. Any way you can get Philip Rivers and keep Beanie Wells?

Trending News

Should I do this trade?

4 Answers