X FACTOR USA ..worst TV reality show?

How did they play dirty? First of all, LA Reid was of course going to back up his act, Marcus. Second, Nicole really liked them both so she couldn't chose who she wanted to send home she made it a deadlock. Rachel had the fewest votes so she was sent home. How is crap is that playing dirty? WTF.

Um, all the judges have supported their acts when they've been in the bottom two! Including Simon. But, I guess he's playing fair by your standards since you agree with his decision. I thought Marcus Canti did the best in the save song and I thought he should have stayed. As much as Rachel is adorable, I didn't think she was the best during the save song. And, I agree with the other poster that her reaction to losing was over the top and almost bratty.

And, I think Nicole is well qualified to be a judge. She's a singer so she knows what she's talking about. She's in the business and she knows what it takes to succeed. It's not like they picked some grandma off the streets who's been a housewife all her life. You might not agree with her decisions, but she's definitely qualified to judge a singing competition.

Blame America that Rachel went home. And, even if Nicole had clearly chosen someone, how do you know she would have sent Marcus Canty home? You're just assuming she would have picked Rachel.

If you didn't vote and you're upset that Rachel went home then you have only yourself to blame. Canty got more votes than her. It just shows how important is to vote for your favorite always and regularly because they can go home at any time.

It's not one of the best reality TV shows for sure..I watched it for the first time...there are of course the breaks after every song...as this is a cheap sort of entertaining people to give them Reality TV...it costs less than movies to make some people dance or sing...but I actually prefer American Idol because the judges are not emotional wrecks...Nicole just is emotionally not capable to be a judge, she often cries..this time she had a nervous breakdown because she could not decide between Marcus and Rachel ..but come on, Marcus is not a bad singer but he has been in the bottom twice before so it's obvious America want's to see him go. Rachel should not have been sent home..she is a better singer than Marcus...and this coming week Marcus will be in the bottom again...if they safe him a 4th time then it's really more than ridiculous..He has been made to sing for survival 3 times now..if he gets saved one more time..then this show really is pathetic...America gives him low votes...even if America obviously gave Rachel Crow the lower votes ..but he should have gone home instead..one can't blame L.A. Reid, he is a partial judge when it comes to his ''boys'' then he will of course rather send one of the girls home..but Nicole was an impartial judge..as she is the mentor of Josh...so nothing to do with the boys and the girls..she should have made a decision..She is a grown up woman..it's ok to have emotions and to show them a little bit...better than acting like a machine, that would be terrible but Nicole is not cut out to be a judge...she did also not make any comment when the host Steve Jones asked her..she was deeply emotionally in a turmoil..she is too emotional a person to be a judge..I prefer American Idol...People seem to forget that only one person can win the 5 million dollar recording contract. On American Idol there was more of a cameraderie between the performers, and whether they won or lost they hugged and they held hands before Ryan Seacrest revealed who would be safe and who would be in danger or going home...Maybe to be the winner of only a 1 million recording contract did not get them upset that much if they did not make it...it seems that 5 million dollars is what everybody has on their minds now and that amount of money can corrupt minds and Steve Jones always has to stand between the two who have to sing for their lives...Ryan Seacrest never did that..and on his show ...they comforted each other...they also were disappointed when they were sent home but they held hands to await the results..and that's not possible because Steve Jones has to stand between them...

Yes, Nicole is definitely not cut out to be a judge, she should finish this as she has to mentor Josh as long as he is on the show..so she should see it through...but after that they should definitely find a replacement for her and she should offer to not do it again because she must realize that this is way too much for her nerves...It's a hell of a messy show lately...the judges turn against each other...they are more immature than the contestants...L.A. Reid...he may have spotted talents such as Rihanna and Usher and Justin Bieber but he intimidates me and Nicole she has a weak nervous system...I don't like either of them two as judges...x

L.A. Reid and Nicole are the only reasons I hate watching X Factor USA. Other than that, the show is pretty good. And I agree, Nicole should go home, she sucks at being a judge.

I don't think LA Reid was playing dirty - the mentor will always choose to save their own act. Simon was at least honest about it.

Nicole wimped out, that's for sure. She didn't let it go to deadlock because she couldn't decide, she just didn't want to be the one to send anybody home. BUT America was the one who didn't vote enough for Marcus or Rachel, America was the one who put those two in the bottom two, and America was the one whose lack of votes sent Rachel home!

Nicole is a coward but America sent Rachel home. And after her overdramatic reaction, I think Rachel deserved to go!

I cant believe you're still thinking its "revenge". What about when Simon sent LeRoy home by deadlock after Le Roy clearly out sang Marcus in the save me song? It seems like there is a double standard. Why is there a deadlock in the first place? America's votes sent her home.

To answer your "question", no watch MTV, they are home to the worst reality TV shows ever.

LA Reid did not play dirty, he is going to support his act no matter what so shush. Don't blame for Nicole for America not giving Rachel more votes.

No, it's not the worst and you're just mad your favorite went home

i wouldn't say it's the worst reality show.I would give that to Jersey Shore or Kardasians

But i think Simon needs to get better Judges and Host.I don't think Nicole will be back next season.I understand why LA Reid voted for Marcus to stay cuz he's part of his category.Even LA Reid did say that Rachel was better though

i did no longer watch it. Why are you posting that style of question here? are not there greater proper venues to communicate this form of ingredient? As for worst actuality teach on television... infrequently. That call is an absolute toss up. My money is on the two The Jersey Shore or the actual Housewives. All this "actuality" television is pathetic besides.

I kinda like the show because it has some real talent, but i'm not 100% on the judges... they could of got better people