Week 15: Eli Manning or Tim Tebow?

Question

Eli is at home against the Redskins defense, which is ranked 13th against the pass. Tim Tebow is going against the worst pass defense in the league, HOWEVER, he doesn't throw the ball that often so I don't know how much that will factor into his production. New England is ranked 13th against the rush so that's another factor I have to consider if playing Tebow.

Both are at home, but Manning and Tebow (statistically) do better on the road as opposed at home. Tebow isn't really that great, but puts up decent numbers due to how well he plays in the 4th quarter.

Anyway, just looking for some outside opinions

RJ · Accepted Answer

Hard to bet against the patriots.  you can bet belichick and brady are not wanting to be another story line in the tebow story so i imagine after all these weeks and film he'll have a decent game plan.  on the other hand, the giants need to win, and eli manning is a beast with so many targets.  I'd go with eli, as I expect he'll put up at least 250 yards and a couple of TDs

Der · Answer

Fisrt off : I manage 5 fantasy leagues . Ranked #1 in 3 of them, #3 and #5 the 2 others 
.

Redskins may be 13th but have you looked at the Giants' past games and the defenses that Eli has played?

Tebow does not put up a lot of points now that they have him figured out. I say he will get about 15 points total. Eli should ge 22+

make your pick.

I chose Eli

Jason Quinn · Answer

Manning 

Answer Mine??
http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20111214055957AAeeQXR

A. Peaney · Answer

Manning.  No doubt about it.  He has been great lately.

Trending News

Week 15: Eli Manning or Tim Tebow?

4 Answers