Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 4

Can something exist without time,matter and space?

Various pieces of evidence point to the reality of the Big Bang (i.e., that all matter, energy, space, time, and forces of the physical universe came into existence at an instance about 13.7 billion years ago).

The second law of thermodynamics (shows that the universe can not be infinitely old, or else it would have run out of usable energy, i.e., it would have reached heat death, or maximum entropy)

A friend of mine (physics major) recently told me that intelligent life exists outside of time,space and matter.

Many modern physicists are finding evidence of many more dimensions (at least 10).

In Michio Kaku's book Hyperspace, he details this and modern 'string-theory' which says all matter is composed of vibrating strings (or vibrations).

"A friend of mine (physics major) recently told me"

intelligent life exist outside of our solar system.

The modern Science does not explicitly confirm or deny the existence of intelligent life in outside of time,Space and matter.

There may be intelligent life on other solar systems(outside of time,Space and matter).

PROOF:BLACK HOLES.

Update:

@Damocles

Nice explanation and thanks.

Update 2:

@godless

Without time, matter and space -- there is literally nothing.

Humans and creatures-impossible

"IMPOSSIBLE WITH MANKIND, POSSIBLE WITH GOD"

13 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Time, matter and space exist only in the physical realm. There is a spirit realm as well. Perhaps this will answer some of your questions (or at least get you thinking about the possibilities) ...

    http://www.thebereancall.org/node/3884

  • Janet
    Lv 5
    9 years ago

    Back 2000 years ago, we had a limited idea that something did exist. We did not know what the universe was, what big bang was, what linear time was, nor what life would be like without linear time. But we knew there was a being who basically was eternal which meant "non linear", the being was non corporeal, and the being could take shapes, and the being was a substance beyond our imagination.

    To challenge this idea of an all powerful entity, the question was posed: Can this being create a rock it cannot lift? If it can't then it can't be all powerful, and if it can, then it can't be all powerful. The answer to this was by Thomas Aquinas who answered this with a question 1000 years ago that asked: "Can this all powerful being create a circle with more than 360 degrees". Oddly enough we know there are circles without 360 degrees; and we developed a math from that challenge. Can this being create a place where weight has not meaning, can it create a place where time has no meaning, can it create a means to remove time or to remove matter. And of course we now know the answer is yes. While we are not able to comprehend the nature of this substance (a biblical term to describe God found in scripture) we must realize we only have a vague idea of what he/it must be like.

    If you want to imagine this substance we call God as our forefathers did 2000 years ago try this: Get an old sand our glass and imagine you are living as the sand flows, and the sand at the bottom is past and the sand above is to come. God is not in the sand but rather God is the hourglass. Now tip the glass on it's side. See how the glass makes the sign of infinity. Infinity is not just everlasting but non linear, which is why it loops. Now using math create a forumula for God and Jesus: and you'll see that infinity plus A is infinity. Thus Jesus is God and of the same, which is just a general concept that anything of the substance of God is God.

    I hope this helps you think of it and those around you a bit better.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, in fact God Created time, space and matter so he exists outside of mater, we dont say the universe in infinite we say God is infinite and since he exists outside of time because he created time he is. the universe was created around 10,000 or so years ago, there is more proof for that then an old earth yet all the evidence is ignored because it is inconvenient to the current beliefs of science, and yes there is probably inteligent life out there somewhere but the universe is vast and the chances for it elsewhere are slim or a planet to suport life it must be in the Galactic and solar habitable zone and there are many other conditions

    just a few things in response to your questions, i could type more but people re complaining about walls of text

  • ?
    Lv 7
    9 years ago

    Your "question" is rather confused.

    Without time, matter and space -- there is literally nothing.

    So far, the concept "of many more dimensions" has no reliable evidence backing it. It's just a useful concept that seems to help make sense of our absurd physics.

    Other solar systems are not "outside of time, Space and matter." They are part of our universe.

    For more, watch the video at the 1st link - "A Universe From Nothing" by Lawrence Krauss.

    -

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 9 years ago

    That sure is a confused mess of gobbledegook. Let me try to make some sense of it.

    A friend of yours, whom you think is smart, said something stupid and you credit it. You are deeply confused by certain theoretical models used by physicists to try to explain things they do not clearly understand, You want to know if something can exist without time, matter, and space.

    First, I will make this a lot easier for you by saying, your friend is wrong. Intelligent life cannot exist outside of time, space, and matter. As a simple matter of logic, something cannot exist and be both something and nothing at the same time. That is a violation of logical possibility.

    Second, I will clear your mind about the theories you do not understand. 10 (and 11) dimension theories, string theory, and other theories are merely mathematical models which physicists use to model behavior of particles in their research and are not intended to represent reality as it is. They are no more realistic than that globe with the spindle through the middle as a model of the earth.

    Finally, you can relax in the knowledge that none of this has any significance in your daily life. You can go to your job, eat your lunch, sleep with your girlfriend, without knowing or caring about the underlying structure of the fabric of the universe.

  • ?
    Lv 4
    4 years ago

    a million) area and time are correct at the same time, because of the fact of the two wide-unfold and particular relativity 2) not something with mass that travels on the exterior of the universe may well be speeded as much as or previous the fee of sunshine. As to what could take place interior the hypothetical "What if" gadget? Time dilation may well be expressed as an uncomplicated formula: gamma = a million / sqrt(a million - v^2 / c^2) the place v = speed of the object c = velocity of sunshine gamma = the dilation ingredient Now undergo in suggestions that it incredibly is suitable to issues shifting alongside the exterior of area-time. Wormholes and different such suggestions are exceeded over (dealing with a wormhole has similarities to reducing around the middle of a race music and putting forward your self the winner given which you chanced on the shortcut; a similar regulations do not inevitably word). v = n * c the place n = % of the fee of sunshine gamma = a million / sqrt(a million - nc^2 / c^2) = a million / sqrt(a million - n^2) Now, in case you plot this graph out, you would be conscious that as n techniques a million, you head for an asymptote. The slope of the line techniques infinity and not something exists for n >/= a million temporarily, please do not divide by utilising 0.

  • AEF
    Lv 7
    9 years ago

    Fallacy of compostion: You are assuming what is true inside of the universe of all or some of the parts applies to the whole (that the 2nd law of thermodynamics applies to theuniverse as a whole).

    What about quantum mechanics? Bell's Theorem? How does that factor into your claims.

    A friend of your who is a physics major is not reliable just because they are a physics major. They could have been indoctrinated during childhood to believe irrational things and are trying to 'rationalize' their belief.

    Modern science, let alone the human brain, has so far been unable to identify/conceptualize things outside of time/space/matter. We don't have ideas on these things because all of our ideas are based on experiences (i.e. Empiricism). And 'existence' is defined in terms of time/matter/

    space.

    Answer: I don't know

    Source(s): @ Stacy, you're appeal to ignorance and special pleading fallacy are quite a bore.
  • ?
    Lv 5
    9 years ago

    That's the nature of the Spirit, my friend. Time is an event that is in a cycle. It's like that wheel within a wheel vision that ever repeats itself. Adam is not the first human on earth but he replenished the end of life that was lost because of Satan rebellion. Adam was the prison guard of the prisoner Satan. Our present earth was recycled from the destruction of the last one between Genesis 1 verse 1 and verse 2. A lot of Christians were mistaken of using the word "create" after verse 3. It was "And God said". The drama of life on earth was in ever increasing rise of Messiahs, from the simplest plant life, animal life, and human life. Fossils told us the truth and they testified to the history of the rise and fall of the species. But the next one was always far superior than the next one and more handsome if you can compare the present human Adam to the Neanderthal. The next one are spiritual humans, chosen from the Kingdom of Israel for their purity from idolatry and from the Gentiles for their loyalty to their Master Christ Jesus. A new heaven and a new earth will come from the ashes of the final war of Satan and Christ Jesus after the 1000 years of Christ rule. This would be the end of the 7000 year cycle and a new one will come. Paradise will be restored back and those proven fit to live there will continue the next wheel of life, spiritual. The end of the last cycle of 777 x 7 days cycle that totalled 402 x 777 x 7 days plus 1040 years or 7000 years. The day of Sabbath, the 7th day will end and a new day will come. Glory to Yahweh.

    Source(s): 777thSabbath.com
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    You have no freaking clue what you're talking about, do you?

    "...on other solar systems(outside of time,Space and matter)." <- Example. Other solar systems are ot "outside" of time and space. And what the hell does it mean to be outside of matter?

  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    Concepts exist.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.