Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

How did the Marines operate in Vietnam?

I've a question that none of the history web sites or books on the Vietnam War seems to address- during previous wars, the United States Marines were a self contained organization and operated as their own integrated package of ground forces, naval, and air support (I.E. they had their own Marine air support and didn't require support from the Air Force like the Army did), so they were lethally effective as assault troops...but during the Vietnam War the descriptions the Marines gave during their operations didn't really sound significantly different from what the army and air force was doing- marching through the jungle looking for the enemy, ground attack aicraft bombing the Ho Chi Minh trail, etc.

How were the Marines deployed differently during the Vietnam War from the other services according to their operational capacity? Were they still employed as an integrated assault force, or or were they essentially deployed piecemeal as another army and and another air force?

No, this isn't a homework question. My father was a Marine during WWII so it's a "what if..." question.

2 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Before WW I they were primarily used as shore parties and guards on warships and Naval facilities. With the steam age they were given the additional task of manning one of the guns.

    During WW I the US needed a couple of quick divisions to ship to France as quickly as possible. They rounded up Army Unites from scattered forts around the country and crated the First Division, and rounded up Marines from the various duties they were performing (often guarding ship-yards and Navel Stations) and created two of the Regiments of the Second Division. The Marines fought as standard infantry in France. They got a lot of press, and POd the Army off as showboats (not that they didn't deserve the credit).

    During WW II they were organized into their own Division sized units, and employed as landing parties by the Navy in their push across the Central Pacific. They were supported by Naval Warships and air in addition to their own close support aircraft. But they were never as completely on their own as you indicate.

    After the war they developed the specialty of over the beach assault and were often deployed as self-contained Regimental Combat teams. During Korea they were used as firemen to plug holes in the line around Pusan until MacArthur pulled them all out of the line and used them to invade Inchon. For the rest of that war they pretty much operated as standard infantry calling on any air-support (Marine, Navy, or AF) available when needed.

    The first Marines were deployed in Vietnam to secure the big Air Base at Da Nang in the Northern part of South Vietnam. There was a lot of speculation at the time that, because they were considered shock troops, the US might be building up for an invasion of North Vietnam. As their duties expanded from security to ground operations they fell into a routine not unlike that of WW I and Korea where they operated as standard infantry. They were supported by their own air-groups, but could (and did) call on Navy and AF aircraft when necessary.

    After WW II, Korea, and Vietnam there were a lot of calls to roll the Marines into the Army, but the Navy (and Marines) have successfully fought off those attempts. In the war on terror the Marines have been deployed in Iraq and Afghanistan in much the same way as WW I, Korea, and Vietnam. They are being used as infantry far from the nearest body of water. But they still get somewhat more intense training than the standard Army troops, and are still considered shock troops and amphibian warfare specialists. They can still be deployed very quickly as self-contained Regimental Combat teams which make them ideal for quick deployment to hot spots like confronting the Iraqis in Saudi Arabia before the big buildup of Army troops in the early 90s.

    Source(s): Military history buff....
  • Anonymous
    9 years ago

    Give me one operation where they have operated totally unsupported by another branch.....

    Same goes for the Army

    Source(s): Me, 23 years in the US Army
Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.