Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Is it ok for husband to comfort his wife in a sexual way when separated and living with another woman?

LONG story but feel a bit of background info is needed here:

My husband (37 & I'm 36) been together since we were 18, (I fell pregnant first time I had sex with anyone with our eldest child who just turned 17). Anyway, he left nearly 6 months ago saying he needed to sort head out. Found out three weeks later her slept with another woman (46), then found out that he had been with her up to a month before leaving the home.

Been together nearly 18 years, ups and downs like all marriages and truthfully over the past 12-18 months shut down emotionally due to him staying out drinking at least twice a week and coming home so intoxicated he wouldn't remember what he had said or done - drink driving on a number of occasions and not spending weekends with us as a family. (His bio father was killed by a drunk driver when he was young but husband does not remember him - his step-father, who he called dad died in 2010 after a 2 year battle with cancer).

I feel now we did need to separate to reignite the emotional intimacy between us but I never had the courage to actually do it (I was studying the past two years and we have 3 kids, 17, 5 and one with a disability 14yrs - life has it's challenges but felt, as we do love each other, everything would be ok).

I didn't think another woman would ever be involved in this (she had separated from her husband around 12 months ago now, has four children, two have already left home, younger two are 17 and 13).

I tried to shelter kids from the truth for as long as possible but about 8 weeks after he left, he introduced her as a friend - our eldest knew straight away this was a lie so we were honest and told her the truth. He moved from his mothers and in with her and in Jan moved into a new bigger home to accommodate the 5 children when our 3 visit (though our child with a disability hates him and it is a constant struggle in getting her to see him).

So, last week a family member of mine died and husband has been around to see me in regards to this (we were all the same age, and the death was unexpected). It has obviously upset me and brought up emotions that I'm sure hubby has thought about too.

In the days before funeral, he was hugging me while I cried and it was not like hugging a friend. If his new girlfriend knew or saw the way he hugged me she would not be happy as even I would view it as cheating (hands in inappropriate places...) As his wife, I didn't even think about her, though it has made me think since... The day after the funeral, he dropped off our youngest child and stayed for a few hours, again hugging but things went further and even though he said we should not do this, neither of us stopped it. We started to have intercourse, but stopped and kissed and hands were still not where they should be if we were not together until he did finish.

We both said sorry, but am not sure that I should be. He should for I feel he has betrayed his new girlfriend.

He had his phone off all week-end and we talked today regarding other stuff, and have not spoken about what happened on Friday, still acting as though we are separated. He has even said he wants our youngest to live with him one week on and one off, but up to the older two as to what they want to do. I said I do not think it is right to separate the siblings and really don't want my youngest to live with this other woman and her children one week on and one week off...

So, should I feel guilty about what happened between us? I do think it is a bit of karma for her as she knew he was married with three kids and slept with him a number of times before he left. Do I continue on as I have been with the separation and my own life, or do I hold onto the hope that maybe one day we can/do reunite? I know my husband would not tell her about it and I wouldn't as I'm not that kind of person (sometimes I think about it but know it would only cause trouble and sound like a crazy ex wanting her husband back. I'm not even sure that I do want him back after him cheating, as I always said it's a deal-breaker in our relationship! I don't even know if I want him back but sometimes think I've been with him for half my life, only man I've been with and because he is the father of my kids.

Thanks if you have read this and please feel free to ask questions for more info or comment on any aspect of this story as I appreciate the feedback...

SO CONFUSED!!!!

8 Answers

Relevance
  • zoom
    Lv 6
    9 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Don't feel bad or guilty for sleeping with your own husband!

    All's fair in love and war.

    It's up to him to stay faithful to the woman he cheated on you with, although clearly he is okay with cheating on both you and her, so he sounds like a bit of a pig.

    I doubt that relationship will last, I'm sure he'll be back sooner or later.

    I don't advise you to let your five year old live with them, tell him no because you don't think that relationship will last (yup, tell him this) and you don't want to expose your precious daughter to any woman he shacks up with, that you will only consider allowing your child to live there a little longer than a visit, IF he marries that woman, and not before.

    And then get on with you life and date other men, and let him SEE that so he can decide if he really wants to lose you.

  • 9 years ago

    I don't think you're confused. I think you're lonely. For some reason, women just grieve over broken relationships a lot longer than men. Then you hold onto hopes and expectations of getting back with a man who messed around on you the 1st time and is still seeing that woman. Your self-esteem has taken a hit and you have lost your confidence but you don't have to settle for being any man's 2nd woman. Pull yourself together. Stand in the mirror and take a good, hard look at yourself and see the smart, cute, decent woman that you are. Get yourself a new haircut/hairstyle and keep talking to yourself positively until you get your mojo back. When other guys start coming onto you again and seeing what you're seeing your husband should be the last man on your mind. Good luck.

  • 9 years ago

    Dear Confused.

    He is still your husband the other woman can go F**K herself, literally. :)

    That being said. If ya'll agreed to see other people while separated don't be to angry. Separation is a touchy area. If you want your husband back then start wooing honey you have found your opening. Be civil especially since children are involved. Take care of yourself and if you want your marriage fight for it. If not then back off and behave. And let his whore have him. Never feel guilty for being intimate with what is by law yours. You have done nothing wrong together you are married. He is doing wrong by being with the other woman. The situation seems to be in your favor to decide what you want. Its up to you. Good luck honey you need all the luck you can get.

  • ?
    Lv 6
    9 years ago

    I dont know why you would want to get back with a man that has hurt you like that....he cheated and is still with her...is it her karma...yes it is....should you telll her? I would...because I would want her to feel what she did to me....I know you feel like he is the only man for you now....but the truth is this...he not...he's not even a good man....you been so pentoup in this marriage that ypu feel like you dont deserve better. Well you do..and if you give it sometime, you will see that there are alot of real great guys out there that would never cheat on you....but if you continue to be with your husband then you can never emotionally move on....which is exactly what you need to do.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 9 years ago

    He is your husband.... I don't think you should feel bad or apologize for feeling attracted to your own husband. There is a lot of history (almost 20 yrs) and you can't lose emotions over night. I think your husband should try to make a decision and stick with it but you did not do anything wrong. I would not throw it in the other woman's face b/c it will just make you look petty.

  • 9 years ago

    There is no reason for you to beat yourself up for what happened (it is no big deal and you should first accept that). There is no reason to feel guilty and tear yourself up - he is confused and needs advise. I think you should move on, find new friends and a partner as well and take care of your children. If you have further questions and need disinterested advice, drop me a message.

  • 9 years ago

    Well he cheated on u hun so don't be suprised he's cheating on her. Move on darling don't wait for him to finish his affair and come back like your just sloppy seconds. When love is one way it never works. X

    Source(s): Life
  • 9 years ago

    Im not going read the entire post. If you want him back make him jealous, period. Its never ever ever ever going to work if you guys live together you think I'm wrong? Your guys got married lived together and now ya know it ant working is it?

    Start going out clubbing. He will be back in no time.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.