Looking for a crappy horror movie that came out sometime between 2001 and 2006.?

This was my last ditch effort and I'm telling you right now that I barely remember anything. I can tell you that it was a really crappy horror film that no one I know has ever heard of but for some reason, I really loved it. I'm pretty sure it started with a D. This is what I remember. It was a Supernatural horror film and it involved orphans at an orphanage going into the woods and doing a Satanic Ritual because one of the orphans told them to. They do it. Now, some-odd years later, I think someone else is going to do the same ritual which... I think made everyone who originally do it die? I'm really vague here and all I can really remember is that woods scene. There's one main guy who either is the guy who originally wants them to do the ritual or is the twin of the guy who wants them to do it. It probably came out closer to 2001, I remember watching it when I was pretty young. I saw it at blockbuster and grabbed it on a whim. I've looked through lists and lists for years and can't seem to find it. Hopefully you'll have better luck than I do!