If you where in the walking dead who would you want to lead the group?

i would follow rick, he is loyal, and just as deadly as shane, but with a conscious, in such a strange world

I disagree.

Well, yes, on a one to one basis I would trust Rick more.

But as a group, I trust Shane more and would want him to lead the group.

Example 1: If Rick and Otis had gone out to get supplies to save Carl's life, do you think any of them would still be alive? Remember, Otis and Shane were both injured and practically out of ammo. They were going to die, and by extension, Carl. Rick wouldn't have sacrificed Otis, and thus they all would have died. By sacrificing Otis, Shane saved two lives, his and Carls.

Example 2: That crazy old coot Herschel was putting zombies in that rickety old barn. Rick finds out and what is doing? He's herding zombies for crazy old Herschel. Shane finds out and exterminates the threat.

Example 3: Shane lied to Lori to get her back to safety vs. letting her wander about in the night looking for her husband. Probably saved her life, especially that she was injured.

Rick is definitely more moral, but that puts the group in more danger.

Rick hes still human

Rick...I can't STAND Shane. He's gonna get the whole group killed because of his arrogance.

Rick.

Shane is too much of a hothead.

Otis because he came back human and hes hawtt and he is a good zombie slayer

NEITHER....i would want......,

wifey-short hair.....coz she got that douchy husband of her's beaten to a stinky pulp and made into zombie sushi without having to lift a finger....;-)