when successful astrologer fails on horoscope of twins then does this mean that all time he was just lucky ?

horoscope predictions need not always be correct/accurate - it is only a guidance need not be a guarantee. in case of twins it need not be alike in all cases.

Hi,

This is very good question and always confused the astrologers.When I came across the this thing first time , when I was doing Astrological Thesis on Mentally retired children , I found 3 twins in which one child is normal and another one is MR. that time I also confused but there is very good method in Vedic Astrology to find out the "difference".

For your Information there is At least 4 minutes difference in the birth of twins, Which is sufficient to have different horoscope , if you check it minutely You will not get nay difference in d9 chart also.

So go for d60 Chart.You will get the answer for your Above 5 questions.

Hope this will help.

All the best , your question shows that "Still you are not thinking only but also doing study"

First, astrology is supposed to predict trends, not exact events. (Per an astrologer friend). Our choices and other's choice affect the impact of those trends.Free will still exits, even in the world of astrology.

Second, there's more than just the sun and the moon in a chart. Just because people are twins doesn't mean they will have identical charts and identical lives. You are assuming that twins have to have identical charts.

I don't particularly believe in astrology, but your presumptions are invalid.

I personally think that astrology is a joke, but there are some strange cases where they happen to b completely correct about your day. I wouldn't look into it that much though because then if u start to believe that stuff then u try to avoid things that it says to avoid, and really none of that really ends up being true any ways. The only time they get that stuff right is by luck. I would suggest not to pay attention to it.

Astrologers are not immune to the effects of their own horoscopes. If the astrologer is going thro malefic dasha/antras etc, then his success rate in predictions is also suffers.

Accurate predictions are made on basis of logic , intuition and knowledge/experience of astrologer.

In astrologers own chart, if there is a benefic planet in 2h or aspecting 2H, during its periods it can give vak siddhi provided he lives/earns honestly.

No, If you follow the course of logic, you may not reach this conclusion. Any form of science is not 100% accurate...To err is human...he could have made a mistake.

But you can in general suspect that the whole branch of astrology is fraud.

I had heard somewhere that first twins child birth chart should be seen from asc and second child from MOON SIGH. try ones ?

All tests of astrology and astrologers (the rare times they subject themselves) have the same results. No better than random chance. A "successful" astrologer makes a good living convincing others he is for real.