Should I retreat now?

I just need a little bit of advice. I've been dating two guys for very long time now both of whom I love. They both love me as well, and ironically they love each other. Should I give a bit of background? My first boyfriend, let's call him John, and I met my second boyfriend, we can call him Pauly, and immediately we all hit it off. We share everything: life, love, money, sex. We all make each other happy. None of us were ashamed of our relationship. Pauly and I live on a college campus, so naturally people questioned us often whenever we first came out. Now that movie has come out," Savages," a bit of an issue is stirring with the public. I never thought what we had was wrong. We're best friends, and I love them equally. Is it wrong?