Which Manning brother would you trust to win you the game down a TD with one minute left on the clock?

Question

Lets also say there are no timeouts left and you are at the opponents twenty yard line.

It just amazes me how good these two are. The Giants coming back against the Buccaneers and the Broncos nearly defeating the Texans.

Boise Brett · Accepted Answer

Depends when in the season it is.  If it was the regular season, gimme Peyton.  If it's playoffs, gimme Eli

Obadia Nerfgirtle · Answer

After that shaky week of Peytons, and Eli coming straight off a super bowl win, I would go with Eli right now, but lets see how Peyton returns because there is no doubt he has the leadership skills to do it

E · Answer

On the opponent's 20-yard line, I'd take Peyton all day. He has more experience and knowledge and he'd make sure the right plays were run to give his team the best chance of getting it in for the TD.

Austin · Answer

I have to go with Peyton Manning. He has done it time after time. I know Eli did it twice in the super bowls but Eli is one of the luckiest quarterbacks in the NFL. If it wasn't for amazing catches in the Super Bowl he would have lost.

Anonymous · Answer

Eli he is best in those situation and I also dont know what to expect from Peyton yet h

Anonymous · Answer

Eli proved why he's a clutch performer in the 4th. I dont know the stats for 4th quarter, by heart, but it's impressive.

Lauren the Football Princess · Answer

I`d go with Peyton. He`s like a machine and he runs on auto pilot. Both are safe bets of course, but I gotta go with Peyton on this one.

MC · Answer

If it is a post-season game- Eli.

Premdog Millionaire · Answer

are you kidding me? eli no doubt. peyton has almost nothing left in the tank but eli is still in his prime

Trending News

Which Manning brother would you trust to win you the game down a TD with one minute left on the clock?

9 Answers