Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Jimz
Lv 4
Jimz asked in Politics & GovernmentLaw & Ethics · 8 years ago

Someone tried to take away my freedom of speech?

This has been haunting me for years now. A couple of years ago in my preteen years, my father and I was at an electronic store (Radio Shack to be exact), We were just browsing and I over heard this lady saying "T-mobile is just too expensive for me." I immediately recommended her an alternative cellular carrier saying that its cheaper. Then the lady behind the register said "Uh, we don't talk about other competitors in this store." I forgot what she said afterwards but her tone was more like "you better not talk about it or else." Then I just nodded and didn't saying anything else.

Did she try to take away my freedom of speech?

Who's wrong here?

Update:

Thank you all for your responses, please don't hesitate to answer, I'm glad to read your responses.

14 Answers

Relevance
  • 8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    On a personal level I would say that she saleswoman over-reacted, but no, that does not constitute taking away your freedom of speech. You could have kept talking if you wanted to. If she wanted to go as far as to kick you out of the store for your words, then she does technically have the authority to do so since the store is private property, the owner has the authority to refuse service to you or kick you out for any reason, and the saleswoman is acting as a representative of the owner. I doubt he'd be too happy with her after the fact, though. The first amendment protects you from being persecuted by the government for your words. You don't have the right to go onto private property and say whatever you want any more than she has the right to come into your home and say whatever she wants.

    Personally, I would have probably told the saleswoman to piss off and gone from there. But no, your right to free speech wasn't violated.

  • 8 years ago

    The store clerk is not the government. They can request that you not speak about the competition till they're blue in the face. The extent that they can enforce their rule is to kick you out of the store.

    Personally, if I were in that situation, I would have turned to the other customer and commented something like, "So, they wont talk about their competition to you... Aren't you glad I'm here to let you know" (You are not part of that "we" -- you don't work for Radio Shack).

  • 8 years ago

    "Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances."

    At what point were you criminally punished by a law passed by Congress for what you said???

    The right to free speech is not "freedom of speech", it means that laws cannot be passed by the Government limiting what you say. Private individuals can exercise their own rights to limit what you say though.

    Your 1st Amendment rights were not violated (not even close) and you absolutely could have been thrown out of the store (a private company) for interfering with their business. When on private property you have no "freedom of speech". The owner of the property sets the terms and conditions of you being there, and when in a store you have no right to interfere with their business.

    Bottom line, you were in the wrong here.

  • 8 years ago

    The government cannot restrict free speech. However, private companies don't have to provide a venue for you to express your opinions. That is, a store doesn't have to allow you to tell its potential customers about other stores. Internet forums don't have to allow you to express disruptive or even just unpopular opinions, etc. A newspaper is not obliged to publish your letter to the editor.

    You are free to buy and operate your own store, or provide your own forum, or start up your own newspaper, and express your opinions. The government can't shut you down for that, unless you're compromising national security.

  • 8 years ago

    You are. The 1st amendment, or your Freedom of Speech, protects you from having the GOVERNMENT try to restrict your rights. There is no provision about a store clerk telling you not to say something.

  • 8 years ago

    You are wrong.

    Freedom of speech deals with GOVERNMENT controls on speech. It protects you from being arrested for what you say.

    You were on private property. You have no right to be in private property if you are behaving inappropriately - and trying to convince another customer to buy a competitor's product is very inappropriate. The employee had the right to tell you to shut up. She had the right to tell you to get out. She had the right to ban you from the store.

  • 4 years ago

    a million. that's not obama it relatively is a team in missouri performing independantly in missouri to inforce a regulation that stops merchandising that is fake. 2. it relatively is already a criminal offense to assert untrue subject concerns approximately human beings, it relatively is observed as slander and you would be sued for it. that's not a count variety form of loose speech, it relatively is an argument of telling the reality and being in cost for what you're asserting. you will possibly be able to assert each and all the undesirable property you like approximately Barrack Obama, in actuality make particular what you're asserting is actual, do in actuality not make stuff up.

  • 8 years ago

    It's there store and private property. You're talking up a competitor of the product they sell and hurting their business. Of COURSE they can tell you not to do that. Do you think freedom of speech would allow you to walk into someone's store and start talking about how bad their product is?

  • 8 years ago

    You have no business to interrupt or interject into ongoing transactions between Radio Shack and random customers. You offered your two cents, you were rightfully told to butt out, and by own will acted upon what he clerk told you to do.

  • Pat
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    The first amendment to the US Constitution prohibits ONLY THE GOVERNMENT from restricting speech.

    Anyone else, anywhere, any time can tell you not to say something.

    If they have some authority over you, they can enforce it.

    And yet, YOU are too lazy and stupid to READ THE DAMN THING.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.