Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Dasha calculation should be from Lagna or Moon ?
Moon is a real object in the sky but Lagna(rising sign) is just a point.
I often calculate Vimshottari from Moon but read the Chart from Lagna.I think considering Dasha from different planet may mean something.I think Dasha from Lagna means something and Dasha from moon means something.
Moon represents our mind.If somebody have strong and stable mind then do you think that dasha calculated from moon may not affect that person much.I am saying becayse Dasha keeps chagning which also changes environment and state of mind of people but if perosn have strong mind then these changing dasha may not affect them much.
What we should see when Dasha is calculated from Lagna.Lagna often stands for physical appearance.Do you think we should see Physical chnages from Lagna Dasha and mind changes from moon Dasha.
I think i have not expressed my idea clearly.Vimshottari Dasha is generally used.To calculate this dasha we see position of moon in particular Nakshatra.But there are more methods in which placement of sun in particular nak is seen rather than moon.This is based on moon.Then vimshottari is also calculated considering Lagna.so in Lagna based vimshottari Dasha Lagna is placed in which nakshtras is seen then dasha is calculated.
I came to know about all this from sanjay rath's book"vimshottari and udu Dasha"
Krishnamurti has suggested to calculate dasha based on Rising sign in case of Twins.
6 Answers
- ?Lv 78 years agoFavorite Answer
i can't understand what you say or what you want exactly . but i think that my answer may clear your doubt.
there are two types of predictions. one is based on the birth chart (lagna) which is permanent in nature and will be for throughout the life
the other is gochaara which is temporary and relates to that particular period (like sade sati janmaguru etc etc . it includes dhasa bhukthi predictions also as the predictions are valid ONLY for that specific period) such things are based on moon that is RAASHI only.
dhasa bhukthi predictons are calculated ONLY WITH RELATION TO RAASHI AND NOT LAGNA
EAMPLE libra lagna and aquarious is raashi . when you talk about jupiter dhasa , you should take it as the dhasa of second and eleventh house owner(from moon or raashi) and NOT as 3 and 6th house owner (from lagna)
i think it will be clear now
- friendLv 68 years ago
hello,
Good question !! Your questions are always gives some chance to think.
Anyways I will try to explain my views on this, may be in line with your question up to some extent.
First of all as you said "Moon represents our mind". In our culture mind is origin of all strength and weakness, Another thing without working of mind our BODY will not act. (means without giving commands it will not work,). So it is good to check dasha from MIND (moon) only , instead of lagna.
BEfore we act on any thing, there are thought about the same, without thought ACT is not possible.
After all we get/experience all the things through the MEDIA,which is our body, which is driven by MIND. AS your mind changes there are physical changes get place, like your body, surrounding environment, friends, relatives etc..
There are two types of dasha one from natal moon and in prashna shatra it is calculated from transit moon.which called as a Gochara dasha.
Hope this will help little bit .
Have nice day.
Source(s): Certified Astrologer - Anonymous7 years ago
In my humble opinion, if Rahu or Ketu is positioned in the 6th 12th axis, use the rising degree of the lagna to calculate dasha, else, stick to Moon sign.
- Anonymous5 years ago
Accurate prediction is not possible on the basis of horoscope. We only make guesses on some unexplained & unverified theories, some of which, by chance, come true. The reasons are : 1. The basic concept of astrology that the sun, all the planets and all the stars revolve round the earth, which was believed by people of early days of civilisation, has been proved to be incorrect. Now we know that the earth and all the planets revolve round the sun and the stars have their independent orbits in the galaxy they belong to. But astrology still goes by the belief that earth is at the center and the celestial bodies including the sun, planets and stars revolve around it. IT ALSO CONSIDERS SUN AS A PLANET AS ONE OF THE NABA GRAHAS. 2. Astrology has no relation either with astronomy or any other branch of science, though so claimed. 3. The theory that the planets gain or loose strength (exalted & debilitated) while moving round has no evidence in support thereof. 4. The theories that the planets have mutual friendship or enmity between them has no logical or scientific basis and is simply imaginary. The other theories for prediction of human destiny etc. also do not have any logical or scientific basis. 5. Zodiac signs are imaginary creations by human beings by drawing imaginary lines between stars which are lying millions of light years (distance covered by light in a year running at a speed of 186000 miles per second) away from one another, both vertically and horizontally, for studying the map of the sky and for understanding the universe. 6. It is against the teachings of religion. No religious texts deal with the subject of stars and planets controlling or guiding human life and destiny. 7. Vedas and Upanishads condemned the subject stating that it takes a person to the darkest regions of ignorance.. 8. Great religious teachers, sadhus and saints never preached or advised people on the basis of astrological theories. Some people claim that a number of predictions have come true and therefore ity is a science. But just because a number of predictions have come true, it does not make it a science. It must explain a cause & effect relationship between the planetary position and the predictions and must also explain through experiments and demonstrations that stars and planets affects human life and destiny as per the position of stars & planets as stated in the theories & rules in astrology. Nobody, so far, answered to the points raised above and/or explained and established the cause & effect relationship between planetary position and human destiny and established through experiments and demonstrations that such claim can be scientifically and logically proved.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous8 years ago
we do dasha calculations with what planet is the ruler of the moon's nakshatra.
e.g. Pushya nakshatra as Chandra will be Saturn dasha starting at birth.
i've not seen someone using lagna dasha