Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Is reservation required every where in India ? Why this should be caste based ?

Reservation is a very bad idea. The idea is to uplift the downtrodden. So, it should be financial status based and not the caste based. This very bad idea is only responsible for the various chaos. Right from the Schools the reservation begins, then in the employment this continues. The worst thing is that the reservation exists in the promotion as well. What a rubbish idea ???

If the reservation continues like this, the number 100 would not be sufficient in the days to come. The people of India are very sure about this.

The reservation should be abolished and so that no chaos between the religions and within the religions.

However, to ensure the upliftment of the downtrodden, the poor should be given a helping hand with the reservation. This should be restricted only to the educational institutes. This reservation should not be extended to the job / promotion. The idea of reservation should be abolished in the jobs.

Update:

Hi, Thanks all, for your valuable feedback and time.

5 Answers

Relevance
  • sgc
    Lv 4
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Politicians have made this blunder for making their own vote bank.

    When the caste system was being eradicated by the successive Congress Governments after independence, VP Singh re introduced it by bringing Mondal Commission.

    Now the leaders of all political parties have made their vote banks in their respective castes.

    Now the Yadavs vote for Yadav candidate. Dalits vote for Dalits and Brahmins vote for Brahmins.

    This is why KHICHDI Governments are coming to power, which have made India weak and laughing stock in the world.

    A -10% getter is being admitted in Medical and Engineering Colleges due to reservation, whereas a 90% getter does not get a seat.

    This is why the quality of our Engineers, Doctors and administrative officers is badly declining.

    This is why the corruption is also on increase.

  • Anonymous
    8 years ago

    I think its political game in india for getting support of public they give it when they require for this they can give more than 50%. But i think it can be done by someone that 100% reservation on cast base atleast we don't think that we get job in india. So sorry to say that these politician one day give us a demand of partion of india because some time after general cast joint than they want a new country please stop this because it harmful for india and world

  • ?
    Lv 5
    8 years ago

    Reservation should be banned completely throughout India.

  • audet
    Lv 4
    4 years ago

    the money of the massive activity is working massive in Washington and US public servants are turning out to be a number of it. it extremely is something that we as people, midsection classification can no longer enable or tolerate. the standard public of the Congress that are professional illegals are doing it because of the money and not because of the fact's humane or the rest. they are merchandising their soul and going against the rights of the yankee people. So we ought to save alert and watchful. they are in the two events yet greater in the Democratic occasion. The Democratic occasion is doing each thing to win in the 2008 election if it take merchandising the rustic to the government of Mexico. Now the U. S. government is going to enable Mexican truckers to force in our roads and that they are no longer stressful with regard to the unlawful drugs and unlawful aliens that are going to return by using this new way. There are no longer any controls and no protection for this new ideas of this so referred to as US government. awaken u.s., something is erroneous and the government is a factor of it.

  • How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
  • 6 years ago

    In my honest opinion!!

    Casteism in India is a need at the moment at least for next 50 years. This may sound out of track but it is true. I have seen many people being used by their caste even today. Most affected and backward states like Himachal, Haryana Rajsthan etc. are still in this caste based grouping culture. My own GF left me when she came to know my caste as she was a rajput by her clan after being in 3-4 years of relation, but just dont consider it. I have seen how people can still corner you. Many of my friends has started blocking me on watsapp as my parents never thought of casteism ever and thats why I never had any issues about my caste. When I got to know about my caste I never thought bad and told everyone that I am SC jatt. At that time, I had moved to Himachal for studies, everything came out like I am an Idiot between alot of social intelligents. They have a lot of things to tell you like, their status, royality, goddesses and devta's wills etc. But I say who asks other's castes is himself culprit of this system. I am scheduled Jatt. I never feel bad about it and even my parents grandparents etc. never had bad living or other situations like that. We never took any advantages and policies etc. But still I was cornered just because I am belongs to SC list. Jatts have their own royality but we dont claim it, that is what is called the nationalism as it is in America and other countries. They people dont put surname instead they put fathers name as second names. Every clan even Leather Workers (Chamars) had times to rule in ancient history. I am pursuing for HAS exams and I have read it very clearly. Who changed their gotra got to be known as rajputs. its a real truth and only indian Pundits were involved in this all system.

    In Geeta,

    It has been given clearly that there are four varnas of human. Lower is that who is most impure and uncultured, Highest is those who are most closer to the Brahm (not Brahma here).

    Rajput is not kshatrya actually. A kshatriya is that who has a kshatriya varna, same is with shudra, brahman, vaishya. More a person does yoga meditation, closer he gets to the agni-chakra which opens his mind to nature. He may talk to directly unsensible things then. It has been clearly given, and at this stage a person is considered in brahman varna. More worldly or materialistically a person lives, more closer he gets to world and called as vaishya. Shudra's are fresh born souls, or those who indulges in bad things like robberies, drinking, streetsmokers etc.

    So now, Things comes like. I have visited many places in himachal. Even I was told once, by a person that (he was giving reference to the varn sankar dosha as explained in Geeta - chapter1-43) that marrying in different caste gives varna sankar dosh. But that idiot didnot even know that varn is not (surname) caste but the varna given in birthchart. Four persons born in same family may have different varnas, and that shloka apllies to that not surnames. Surnames are Kullas (clans). Marrying in same clan or different clan does not matters at all.

    If we are not aware of it, we would loose our society to varn-shudras and chandals in coming 500-700 years. We must enforce proper channel to set awareness about these ancient believes and their real values. Pandits and Rajput Society has ruined the caste systems in last 100 years. Please read Kabir and Ramanujs story of being accepted as pupil. Kabir was a very lower caste, but was a brahmin as he was closest to Brahm. Half of india was his believer but no pundit will ever say he was a brahmin, everyone will say he was a lowercaste saint. Because, the root of the system (from where the information comes out to society) is itself corrupted pandits. I dont blaim them. I blaim that when it was clearly written in geeta that a Shudra Varna is not allowed to read religious scriptures. Did they every tried to stop their shudra family members to do rituals and analyse our ancient granthas. A shudra will always wrong interpret them. And live examples are like Baba Rampal etc.

    If they want equality and this casteism to be closed. Then highers should first start to accept lowers. They must try to bring back vedic era. Govt will change in 5 years if it happens.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.