Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Please help. did the cops do anything wrong or break the law?
So my wife just left me recently and made a whole stink about it. I injured my back working so I have been on pain pills and muscle relaxers. She had called the police and had her family come over to help with her stuff and the cops asked me to stay outside of my home. At the time I was just in shorts and socks and it had been chilly outside. When the two cops asked me to step outside I asked if I could put a shirt on and one cop said no don't worry it won't take long. About fifteen minutes later I asked again being uncomfortable because of my body and cold, the cop still said no. I had also asked that her family members not enter my house since they have stolen from me before and I had apologized if that made me seem like am asshole. The cop had said and I quote, ''What you can do to not be am asshole is shut your mouth. Just be quiet and shut up.'' I had complied and I asked if they could get the keys from her so she didn't try to get into my house while at work and the cop had just said not to worry about it. Did they break the law or do anything wrong? I had felt extremely embarrassed and was cold and just felt like I was treated like trash. I have a clean record and have never been into trouble with the law.I live in Texas bt
there was no court order or search warrant. i had just been watching tv and they knocked on my door asked if someone was moving out asked my name and had just ushered me outside leaving one to practically guard me so she could get my sons stuff. i had offered to pack her things. the stuff she took was light and very little to where a kid could lift them.
there was no court order or search warrant. i had just been watching tv and they knocked on my door asked if someone was moving out asked my name and had just ushered me outside leaving one to practically guard me so she could get my sons stuff. i had offered to pack her things. the stuff she took was light and very little to where a kid could lift them.
7 Answers
- Clark KLv 68 years agoFavorite Answer
Did the cops do anything wrong????
You terrified your old lady to the point that she had good enough sense to leave you and take the kid, and she was so scared of you that she called the cops to "cover her retreat". She get relatives to help her get her stuff out. And the cops made you wait outside....The made you wait outside.... Why? because they didn't want you to snap out and beat the snot out of her, that's why.
Congratulations to your wife for having enough sense and self respect to leave you, you bum.
And for all the morons who said the cops need warrants, they need a check up from the neck up. It is just as much her house as it is yours. the cops were just there to protect a probably abused wife.
All the people who said the cops did something wrong are probably asshole wife beaters themselves.
- impaler19120Lv 78 years ago
I have no idea why these folks seem to think the police needed a warrant in that situation. There is absolutely NO reason why a warrant would be needed for your wife to remove HER property from HER marital residence.
I don't want to take sides, but you and your wife are obviously in the middle of marital strife. That leads to violence in many situations. Sh wanted to get her stuff out of the marital home (which she is allowed to do) and she had relatives come help her (which she is allowed to do).
She called the Police because she was obviously afraid of what you would do. There had to be something in you past behavior or demeanor that caused her to call the police. I don't need to know specifics, but it is more than obvious.
The police asked you to stay outside, because they did not want to have to get into the middle of a confrontation between you and your wife or her family. That is something that happens often in these situations. Have you ever heard the expression,"An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure" ?
Becuase your wife feels that she needs p[olice protection to get her belongings away from you speaks volumes about yoru relationship. The police had to be there, becuase once they had been told of a p[otential problem, they would be liable for any harm that you caused her or her familiy of they just left. I am quite sure it was a pain in the 2ss for them, too. I am sure they dio not want to hang out with you while your wife moved out. But, that is part of their job, to keep wives safe.
She is a allowed to let her family enter the marital residence, whether you like it or not. And the polcie continued to keep you outside to keep you apart from everyone else, whether you were cold or not. It was more important that they avoid a confrontation than worry about you being chilly.
They did nothing wrong, perhaps other than refering to you as an asshole. But that was more of a rhetorical question than actually sayin that you are one, so, i think they need a pass on that one.
I know this is NOT what you want to hear. You want the police to be the bad guys, and your wife and your in-laws also bad guys. I have been a police officer for over 40 years. I have no doubt that she would not have called the police to stand by while she moved out, unoless she anticiipated that you were going to act up.
- El JefeLv 78 years ago
It was very unprofessional behavior on their part. If they were enforcing a court order allowing her to retrieve her possessions, they had a right to ask you to leave your home while she got her stuff. But ordering you outside half dressed in cold weather was not appropriate. As to precisely which law they might have broken, that varies from place to place. It may be that there was only a civil violation of some sort, and no criminal violation.
As for allowing others inside the home, if she had large items that she could not carry by herself, she is entitled to have assistance, but no more assistance than she really needs. (She can have her two brothers carry her chest of drawers outside, for example, but she can't have them and her 3 sisters and her father in law and her mother "help" her carry a few photographs.)
The cop's rudeness was also unprofessional and should be the subject of a complaint.
If she was moving out, she has no right to the keys to your place, and the police should have confiscated them on the spot at your request. That should also be the subject of a complaint. If she does not return the keys, you should request the police obtain them (or escort you to her current abode so that you can retrieve them). If they refuse or claim that it is a civil, not criminal, matter, get a lawyer and go to court to get them.
I suspect there will be divorce proceedings in all of this soon, so you'll need an attorney for that, anyway.
- ?Lv 78 years ago
They violated no law. This is how they operate. They make it seem as though you MUST do something, when in fact, you consented.
And they wonder why people hate cops. I guess they believe it is easier to make people fear them then respect them.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- Anonymous8 years ago
Did they have a search warrant? If not, it's a violation of your Right to Privacy (Article 12 if the UDHR).