Is this a good trade?

I'd rather have Kaepernick..

gud loock

Take it. Kaepernick has a better WR group. I like Colston being able to go for tons of points, and I with the Rushing ability of Kaepernick, I would take it. Andrew Luck had 18 interceptions last year, and had the 2nd to last completion precentage in the league. Also, he is projected by the analysis I use, to recieve 17 points per game, as upposed to Kaep's 18. Kaepernick is an injury risk, as is any qurterback who rushes, but Kaep's upside is much more greater than Lucks.

take luck. kaepernick has a big upside yes. but so does luck. hilton was good last year, wayne still there, new coaching will improve that completion % and he throws more than kaepernick will. kaepernick doesnt have crabtree, plays in a much tougher defensive division, and no #2 wr. even if sf defense shortens the field, its still hard to score in the nfc west. luck seems more steady at this point.

It;s a gamble to take Kaepernick. He was amazing last year, but I'm not sure if he can keep it up. I think Luck more likely to have a better season, so I'd keep him.

No. Luck is a better real life QB but in fantasy CK is way better. CK can give you points on the ground and through the air and has more weapons than Luck.

If Kaep still had Crabtree, I would go Kaep without much question. However, without Crabtree, I think Luck is in a better position for success.