Keeper league trade help?

The other guy does. This is a dynasty and Tannehill has a lot of potential so he is a good dynasty QB. Plus Rice is a beast and a top RB and better than any WR this year. Julio is who I would choose but it's still not enough. Even with a 1st round pick the deal is bad because it's not the 5th pick, it's the 5th pick after 200+ players have been drafted. So you aren't getting a stud RB you are getting a rookie RB/WR that may not be able to help your team for a few years. I wouldn't make the deal.

I'd rather have Jones.

But if you were just asking "Jones or Thomas in a keeper league?", then what's with the rest of the stuff? Was that supposed to have an effect on the answer?

Take the 1st round pick instead of the 2nd.

EDIT: Were you asking if you should even make the trade? You couldn't have been, right? You gave us no information on how important Tannehill or Rice is to your team. You might not have a better QB. You might have 3 better QB's.

I think that you get the better end of the trade. I'd take Thomas over Jones in a regular league, but because it's keeper I think you that you should pick Julio Jones. Best of luck!