Hypothetical question -- Who would be the best player in baseball if PEDs and steroids were legalized ?

I ss one glaring problem hypothetically your assuming if they were legal all would use this works right into Budlick Selfish thinking i made it illegal and suspend them so players now clean. History lesson long before Roids and PED there was this game called Coors rarefied wound more tightly baseballs hey lets think Ellis Burks Andres Gallararga super stardom. then came the mystery stuff in walked Brady Anderson and Greg Vaughn the 50 guys. Heck Ellis was rarefied so high he should of made the 50 -50. When you say 50-50 I think your thinking Matt Kemp predictions 2012. Albert Belle did 50-50 doubles HR.

The one guy you can bank on would be Josh Hamilton legal he a 80 HR .400 hitter keep him off crack and on roids. Miggy would not be on the list roids PED and massive cases of beer don't mix. Who to fear on PED Prince Mountain (Fielder).As good loyal fans we must believe the crap we were told though they do effect performance hitting a baseball the hardest thing to do. So what if it adds 200 feet to Brady Anderson we would still be a fly out to short outfield drive we need the talent. Remember and never forget Roids and PED will not make you faster I don't care what banned sprinters in the Olympics have proven Only booze will as Mantle proved 3.1 sec to first 14.3 around the bases. Trout has no track record remember a roid is a roid is a roid but no two roiding players are the same. Imagine how great Ryan Braun would of been if he didn't need to think up excuses and could devote full time to anti-aging.Who is to think that all Herb Washington needed was a needle of roids and some PED and he would of been a 50-50 guy ? 30-30 maybe lol.

As to pitchers heck they can't hit so good maybe Roger just took it to help lay down a sac bunt.

Hmm...well if everyone is clean now then it'd be the same people who are at the top now.

Bonds wasn't the type you would think steroids would help, you'd say he's too long, athletic in smooth.

My firs thought is Carlos Gonzalez, but I mean I think it would shorten some guys defensive careers at least.

Depends on how much they are juicing and what exactly they are taking.

I think it might be best for 1B because they don't have to move much.

Maybe Bryce Harper on juice? He'd be a big kid, like Giambi in his prime. And he has the space to fill out. Trout is already built like a brick shithouse.

I would say Mike Trout no doubt. He'd hit 50-50 every year.

Miguel Cabrera is on PEDs already

Miggy if he was roided up he'd have 200 RBIs he's a beast as it is

Ou have to realize the pitchers would be throwing at insane speeds as well

I'll go with Aroldis Chapman. He already throws triple digits, picture how much harder he could throw if juiced up

Since we don't know who is and who isn't still juicing right now, I don't know how to answer your question without it being purely speculative.