Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

snottyrotty asked in PetsFish · 8 years ago

how much aragonite to add to an established 20 G goldfish tank?

i have a dying fish due to ZERO ph levels. HARD tap water and HIGH acidity in my tap water. NEeding to add the aragonite, but not sure how much. I'm going to be adding it to the filter housing units, which hang, i have 4 in use right now. currently i have about 1 cup stuffed in them now, secured in hosiery bags, but levels on pH and such are not changing at all. Ammonia stays high as does my nitrate levels, and i swear, nothing i do is helping to lower those readings.

this tank has been up and running for maybe 2 years. I just moved to a new home and our tap water is bad. thanks. 2 small goldfish in there. thanks.

heres tank water parameters:

ammonia = 4.0

pH = 0

hardness = 250

nitrite = 0

nitrate = 80

alk = 0

my prized goldfish got a bad case of tail fin rot. almost lost him. I used the API Fungal Cure yesterday. added more aeration and filtration to tank too. PWCs every day till water parameters are in check. thanks.

2 Answers

Relevance
  • Sarah
    Lv 6
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    Wow! Those levels are crazy. Your fish must be suffering:( So sorry you are dealing with this.

    If it were me, I'd be ditching that water completely. I'd buy bottled spring water, or water from a local fish store. Like right now. That much ammonia will cause a lot of damage fast. That level of nitrate can cause poisoning and lead to swim bladder issues. What are your tap water parameters? You should test it immediately. It may not even be safe for you to drink.

    This is from the World Health Organization (WHO):

    "Below pH 4, redness and irritation of the eyes have been reported, the severity of which increases with decreasing pH. Below pH 2.5, damage to the epithelium is irreversible and extensive (10). In addition, because pH can affect the degree of corrosion of metals as well as disinfection efficiency, it may have an indirect effect on health."

    There are no safe ammonia guidelines, but from what I have found, the higher the ammonia, the more faecal matter and impurities that are present in the water. Ew!

    You need to do something fast if that ammonia is from the tap. If it is not, then your tank may have had it's cycle interrupted in the move. Big (50%) daily water changes are recommended until resolved. Not sure if the PH can be balanced enough. I've never heard of a PH of zero in tap water...

    That said, your tank is too small for the fish. They may be creating more waste than the beneficial bacteria can handle. You need 40 gallons plus ten for additional fish (commons) and 30 gallons plus ten for additional fish (fancy).

    Good luck!

  • Gary C
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    If your water is truly hard, the pH can't possibly be zero. Perhaps your test kit is faulty.

    Also, anything with a 0 pH (extreme acidity) would eat right through your pipes and would burn your skin if you touched the water. pH 0 is equivalent to concentrated hydrochloric acid.

    It would take a lot of space to go into the chemistry of this, but please take my word for it.

    Also, an ammonia level of 4.0 ppm is highly toxic, regardless of the pH.

    Forget the aragonite until you can get the ammonia level down to near 0.0.

    Aragonite probably won't harm the goldfish, but it's irrelevant to the ammonia problem.

    Putting zeolite (also called ammo chips) instead of aragonite in those mesh bags might help (zeolite absorbs ammonia from fresh water).

    But you should also find another source of water for your fish tank until you work out what's going on with your tap water chemistry.

    Needless to say, it's also inadvisable to drink water (although water is not the right term for it) with a 0 pH, or even bathe in it or wash your hands with it.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.