Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

Why are my Crash Cymbals brown?

I joined my schools marching band this year, and the crash cymbals I use are... brown.

This question may be lengthly, but please stay, I really need your help!

My cymbals are Sabian, but you cannot see the logo. We just know the brand because they are exactly the same as another pair of cymbals, but the other pair looks nice and clean.

On the top side of my cymbals, they are kind of a brown color with maybe a tint of orange. Some people say it is rust, but the cymbals contain no iron, so it can't be rust, but some kind of acid. And then where the pads are on the cymbal (around the strap on the cymbal) the stuff is kinda rubbed off, so you can see a little bit of its real color, and you can see the stuff on the bottom of the pad.

on the underside, they have some of the brown-orange acid or whatever it is, but it also has some clean and very shiny parts on it (unusually shiny).

Now HERE is a VERY interesting thing to keep in mind, that may help.

While playing at a football game, we set the cymbals on the floor of the bleachers, but someone spilled lemonade on the bleachers. So when we picked up the cymbals, the part the lemonade was touching is now clean, it removed the brown-orange "acid". However, it also left a purple line on it.

Any thoughts? How to clean it, what is on it? PLEASE I would be very thankful!

2 Answers

Relevance
  • ?
    Lv 7
    8 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    What you have is called 'patina'. It's not rust, but a form of oxidation related to the brass alloys used in the instrument. It can be removed by a commercial product like Brasso that the other poster listed, or even removed by the citric acid in lemonade, BUT DON'T DO IT! That patina is cherished professional players. It takes years to accumulate and gives a warmth to the cymbals. What you now have is a great set of symphonic crash cymbals. They're exactly what you want for the concert band, but not so much for a marching band where it's all about bright sounds. There are players who would give their eye teeth for an old set with heavy patina. Don't polish them! It can take decades to get that patina just right. Your cymbals might be twenty or thirty years old. Get a new set for the marching band and keep those beauties for their real purpose. It took years to get them sounding that way and you don't want to wipe it all away in ten minutes with Brasso! I've known professional percussionists that paid HUGE money for cymbals just like those.

    Oh, and the other things you mentioned like the purple line, are exactly what you would expect under those conditions. There's no doubt at all that you have an old set of symphonic cymbals with heavy patina. Don't wreck them.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.