Should I accept this trade?

Without knowing the rest of your team, PPR or not, how many receivers, depth, etc, etc, etc

Cruz is the stronger fantasy play here. Hilton has had two very good weeks (3 TD performance then 7 catches for 100+ yards). However, I believe Cruz, in the bigger scheme of things, is a more productive player. I own both of these players in separate leagues, but if I owned them in the same and a position was open for ONE of these players, 9 times out of 10 I would probably go with Cruz. His chemistry with Eli, the pass-heavy Giants offense (and now with Andre Brown - Cruz can draw less coverage if they develop a running game and play-action), and Cruz's ability to break for big plays is a major asset.

Hilton is definitely a very good talent, but he is a North to South guy, while Cruz works the slot and has ability to get open all over the field.

Both very good players, but I'd go with Cruz.

I would take Hilton at this point. Hilton is now the #1, very explosive. I like Cruz alot, and I have both Cruz and Hilton on my fantasy team, but Cruz has a big problem, and that's a guy named Eli. I don't know what happened to him, but he has a head problem. Throws way too many picks, and look at today's game, missed Cruz wide open for a TD. Both of them will put up points, and I think it's a toss up for who ends with the better season. But when given a tough decision I always go with the better QB, and I think that's Luck right now.

I have both and if offered a trade I would get rid of Cruz before Hilton. He can be explosive where as Cruz surprised me week 1.

I'd stick with Cruz, when all is said and done he will probably outproduce Hilton the rest of the way. With receivers I almost always go with the guy with more of a track record

Stick with cruz. Hilton has great upside but if defenses start doubling him because the colts have no other wr I think he'll struggle

Last year ty lit it up in the second half hes the new #1 with a great quarterback I would take the deal