Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 4
? asked in Science & MathematicsMathematics · 8 years ago

I need help on 2 calculus questions, Volume of A Solid of Revolution?

1. Can you explain the difference between cylindrical shells method and disk method?

I understand that volume is how much an object can hold. Using this idea we apply it to the disk method, πr^2h is the formula for cylinder where h is going to change, so h will be dx then we will integrate it to make h infinity small. But, when we are talking about Shell method 2πrh is the (surface area)? because we are calculating the outside not the inside . Shouldn't be calculate the surface area instead of volume?

2. Can you explain the difference between cylindrical shells method rotating about to x and y and disk method rotating about to x and y?

If it is possible, can you give some links to good videos explaining this?

Thanks

2 Answers

Relevance
  • 7 years ago
    Favorite Answer

    When you revolve a curve about some axis, you produce a solid which has a circular body with some height. At different height, the circular body has different radii. Thus, the magnitude of the radii is related to the heights. That is, r can be a function of h or h can be a function of r.

    2πr is the circumference of the particular circle.

    To find the volume, we write

    ∫∫ 2πr drdh or ∫∫ 2πr dhdr

    , because change the sequence of the integration won't change the answer.

    ∫∫ 2πr drdh = ∫ πr² dh is so called disk method.

    ∫∫ 2πr dhdr = ∫ 2πrh dr is so called shell method.

    Using disk method, we need to express r as a function of h so we can integrate.

    Using shell method, we then need to express h as a function of r to integrate.

    Therefore, which method to choose depends on if r can be a function of h or the other way around. Sometimes, both ways are fine; sometimes only one would work.

    Now regarding rotating about x axis or y axis.

    Rotating about x axis makes y become r and x as h;

    Rotating about y axis makes x become r and y as h.

    Other than that, nothing new.

    One more note about the area:

    ∫∫∫rdrdθdh is the volume expression in cylindrical coordinates.

    Within the scope we are discussing here, we integrate wrt θ first. That is, ∫∫∫rdθdrdh = ∫∫∫ 2πrdrdh

  • 8 years ago

    Yes, you're correct. If you are slicing the volume horizontally into disks, then the volume of each disk is pi*r^2*dh. r will depend on h.

    2pi*r*h is the surface area, not teh volume.

Still have questions? Get your answers by asking now.