Who would you nominate? Hypothetical question.?

You are the runner of your party and need to nominate a winning canidate. You two to choose from.

The first? A tall, handsome charismatic man whos very presence electrifies a room. During interviews, he dodges hardball questions with a smile and well timed one liner. Even his opponents admit he is a rockstar and envy his popularity. Problem is, His political ideology easily fits on a bumpersticker. He is as deep as a pothole.

The second? He is short puffy man with a distinctively bulbous asymeterical face. However, He is an exceedingly gifted administrator. He has a gift for creating plans that anticipate problems and address them on the go. Even his most vocal critics have few legitmate criticisms about him. He is cold in manner and distant. He does slowly inspire by his quiet determination.

You have to pick one that will win the Whitehouse. What do you do?

If insist on picking a real canidate in this exercise, please don't answer.