Poll: Do these cookies sound yummy or disgusting?

Question

My family's oven is broken, but I have to bring cookies for a Halloween party in homeroom on Thursday. I really want to make cookies, so I was brainstorming ideas for no-bake ones, and I thought of making vegan cookie dough (no eggs/salmonella!), putting pumpkin pie filling in between two pieces of the dough, and then pinching it together so it makes a little cookie. (if you're having trouble picturing it, think of like an Uncrustables Sandwich except with raw sugar cookie dough and pumpkin inside, or even like a piece of ravioli made of sugar cookie dough and filled with pumpkin)

I told my mom this and she said this sounded disgusting, and she asked some of her friends she was with and they said it sounded gross too. But I think it sounds good and it seems like a good idea....!

So question is: Do you think that these cookies sound yummy or disgusting?

I told my mom this and she said this sounded disgusting, and she asked some of her friends she was with and they said it sounded gross too.  But I think it sounds good and it seems like a good idea....!

So question is: Do you think that these cookies sound yummy or disgusting?

ChemoAngel · Accepted Answer

I've got a simple, No bake cookie for you. 
They are cute, and easy to make! 
http://allrecipes.com/Recipe/Witches-Hats/Detail.aspx?ms=1&prop25=153799248&prop26=WhatsCooking&prop27=2014-10-23&prop28=Photos&prop29=Link_2&me=1&eaid=14575849

Todd · Answer

Disgusting, mostly because of the raw dough thing. The texture would be off for me. It sounds like a fun experiment, but I probably wouldn't eat it or even consider it a "cookie". But, that's just me. Maybe I'm wrong.

pennybarr · Answer

I agree with your mom, as much as I love anything pumpkin, I don't see filled  pumpkin pie filling holding up in cookie dough.  Here is a link to some filled cookies dough recipe that you might like.
http://picky-palate.com/2012/10/03/no-bake-stuffed-cookie-dough-bites/ -

Katie · Answer

Disgusting.  If the oven is broken make Cornflake/Rice Crispy Cakes - breakfast cereal coated in either chocolate/treacle mixture that are hardened in the fridge.

Myzygo2 · Answer

it doesn't sound very appealing to me.

Maybe you could use an oven at your school.

Our schools had stoves with ovens in the Home Ec. class rooms.

Allie · Answer

Fine

? · Answer

Sounds good to me.

Anonymous · Answer

Good.

? · Answer

i really think that it sounds lovely and everyone will love them once you have made them!!!!!

Anonymous · Answer

yuck! disgusting!

Trending News

Poll: Do these cookies sound yummy or disgusting?

12 Answers