Yahoo Answers is shutting down on May 4th, 2021 (Eastern Time) and beginning April 20th, 2021 (Eastern Time) the Yahoo Answers website will be in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Trending News
Anyone have problems with a Springfield armory XDm rusting? Or any other carbon steel gun rusting?
I only ask this because I'm a stainless steel welder and I know stainless does not rust. I own two guns and both are stainless. So I don't worry about the finish wearing off with use. But the XDm is almost entirely carbon steel. I know Springfield will refinish it, but it just seems like a hassle I don't need.
I put a XDm on layaway without researching material used in the gun. I like the gun but there are others I won't have to worry about. I can get the money back in store credit, minus $25. Not a big deal.
Any opinions would be helpful regarding firearm rust. Thanks!
10 Answers
- Dana HLv 56 years ago
Stainless will still rust when you're getting it wet, just not as bad. I've had my stainless Encore out in the rain and it did get a small area of light rust which was easy to clean off.
There are some interesting corrosion tests people do for all the different products out there for gun oil or CLP that you could sort through on the internet.
- Lime Green MedicLv 76 years ago
I never owned or carried an XD series pistol long enough for it to rust. The extractor problems were enough for me to never want to keep one.
Modern firearm finishes are highly corrosion resistant, and, as others here have said, if you take care of the gun with basic PM procedures, you shouldn't have a rust problem.
And, having worked here in Florida, I can attest to a stainless steel sidearm showing signs of rust. I'll admit, I was surprised, too...the first time.
Edited to add: I am not as enamored with the M&P's finish. You will probably find the XD series pistols to have a better finish than the stock factory M&P. I've actually seen factory M&P's which had rusted in the holster, even with basic PM.
- augustLv 76 years ago
Most guns, including that one, aren't just "carbon steel." They're given a coating of some sort to help retard rust and other corrosion.
For example, Glock uses a process called Tenifer, which is a nitriding process. Springfield and S&W use the same basic process, but call it Melonite.
As long as you actually keep your gun clean and properly oiled, there's no reason to think that it will ever rust.
- How do you think about the answers? You can sign in to vote the answer.
- JeffLv 76 years ago
actually... the early runs of XD pistols did have a rust problem. I understand they figured out the problem and fixed in a few years back.
Shorty G has never carried a pistol full time... Lol... and not all "stainless steel" is totally corrosion resistant. Depends on exactly how it's alloyed and what the working environment is. I had buddies on the Marine detail in Florida who rusted up quite a few "un rustable" stainless pistols on duty
- Russ in NOVALv 76 years ago
Not to worry, non-stainless Springfield XDMs are melonited (nitride surface treatment). The treatment is used on many firearms, including Glocks and some AR-15 barrels and BCGs. Not going to rust unless the melonite is scartched off, which I think is pretty difficult.
Take care of any gun and use this no fangled product, called gun oil, it won't rust.
- Higgy BabyLv 76 years ago
I had the XD for quiet a while. It saw a lot of humidity and lots of exposure to coastal weather. Never any rust.
My old Sig 228 has a carbon steel slide- no rust.
- Space CowboyLv 76 years ago
Never had any stainless guns....never had any problems with rusty guns....and I have used some pretty scuzzy ones, over the years.
Source(s): I actually take care of all my firearms....no matter what they cost...from a $150 pistol to a 1000 dollar rifle. - Anonymous6 years ago
News flash, dude, stainless steel is not rustproof.