Good earrings for previously stretched ears?

I had my ears stretched to 1/2 inch for about a year. I took them out around 8 months ago to heal up. (I was sick of dealing with them. They were annoying.) My ears have healed down to about a 12g, which is just enough to where they look pretty normal, yet can't hold a normal stud without drooping down and being weird. Perfect, right?

Anyways, I'm tired of not being able to wear cute earrings in my first hole. I don't have the intention of re-stretching, so all the earrings I've seen thus far are designed to "show off" how large the hole is. I'm looking for something that looks like a normal earrings, just a bit thicker.

If anyone has any suggestions, ideas, or anything really, I'd appreciate it.

*** My ears are as good as they're going to get. They've been stuck at a 12g for months now, and I've used all sorts of oils. I'm NOT looking for tips on how to shrink them further. It's pretty awesome that they shrunk down this much.